English muffin bread.

When I was a kid, my grandmother made a very specific type of bread for me and my sister that was a staple of our diets, something we’d eat every day for breakfast for about a week until both loaves were gone. It’s a very simple milk bread, but toasted with butter it’s amazing, and, of course, now every bite evokes many memories of childhood and of my grandmother, who died in 2014 seven months after her 100th birthday.

I’ve had the recipe since I left college, but I made it maybe once or twice before she died, even though she pretty much stopped making it in her early 90s when she lost the forearm strength to knead the dough. She died right after Christmas in 2014, and after I came home from the funeral, I made the bread for the first time in years as a way to remember her while I grieved. My daughter loves the bread too, and we make it a few times a year, usually together now because she’s turned into quite a good cook as well. I think my grandmother, whom my daughter was lucky enough to know and will always remember because she was 8 when my grandmother died, would be so happy to know we’re still making that recipe today.

I made this bread last week and posted pictures on my Instagram account, where several of you asked in the comments for the recipe, so I’m posting that here. This recipe calls for instant yeast, which is all I use – I buy bricks of the SAF brand, usually from King Arthur, and keep it in the fridge for years. If you use rapid-rise yeast, you should follow the instructions on the package for that. Also, my grandmother always used all-purpose flour; I have also made this with bread flour, which produces a stronger loaf with a tighter crumb.

English muffin bread

1 cup milk

2 Tbsp sugar

1 tsp salt

3 Tbsp butter

1 cup water

2¼ tsp instant yeast

5 ½ cups (675 g) flour

corn meal for dusting

1. Scald milk, then stir in sugar, salt, and butter till dissolved. Add water to bring to lukewarm (about 115 F).

2. Add yeast to flour, then combine with liquids and stir until a dough forms. Knead about ten minutes on a floured surface until tacky but not sticky.

3. Place in an oiled bowl and let rise until doubled, about one hour.

4. Divide the dough in half, shape into loaves, roll in corn meal (optional), and place into oiled loaf pans. Let rise again until doubled, about another hour.

5. Score the tops of the loaves and bake 25 minutes at 400 degrees, rotating once. Remove from the pans to cool on a rack as soon as you can handle them.

If you’re really into making bread, I can’t recommend Peter Reinhart’s books highly enough, including his Bread Baker’s Apprentice, Whole Grain Breads, and Artisan Breads Everyday.

Comments

  1. This was one of my favorite early breads. The recipe’s slightly different, but the same in the end. I started making muffins recently, instead, as they keep better frozen.

  2. This was one of my favorite early breads. The recipe’s slightly different, but the same in the end. The crunch out of the toaster made it.

    I started making muffins recently, instead, as they keep better frozen.

  3. i’ve been meaning to try making making this. I make the KAF sourdough English muffins all the time. One of my favorite breakfast treats. I either do a simple toasted muffin with homemade strawberry jam or I will l soft poach an egg and serve with a smear of avocado, slice of red onion on a toasted muffin with a splash of hot sauce. Soooo good.

  4. Never made bread before, but this is intriguing. Would this be a good recipe for a beginner, or would you recommend something else to start?

    • It’s about as easy a bread recipe as you’ll find. It’s also a straight dough method, meaning you don’t have to wait overnight for any of it – you can start it at 10 am and have bread before dinner.

  5. What size bread pans does this use? I’ve learned today that I only have one, but it is fairly large: 9.25 x 5.25 x 2. Would I halve the recipe? Thanks!