Top 40 songs of the 2000s.

I had no intention of doing any sort of decade-end list, even when I saw various other “best songs of the 2000s” rankings go by, but when I heard the #2 song on this list on the radio last week I had the idea of doing a blog post about it, and after a few terrible, discarded ideas, landed upon this. This isn’t a greatest songs list – just a list of my favorite songs of the 2000s, with longevity serving as my main criterion: I had to like the song, and like it enough that I still wanted to hear it months or years later. Aside from a few hip-hop songs, it’s almost entirely alternative, with a heavy British influence, which probably just says that my listening tastes have become as narrow as my reading tastes are wide.

40. The Darkness – “I Believe In A Thing Called Love.” The first of several songs on this list to heavily reference 1970s hard rock, with the Darkness unabashedly stealing from the New Wave of British Heavy Metal that brought us bands like Iron Maiden and Motorhead. Wikipedia says this song was on the soundtrack for Bridget Jones: The Edge of Reason, which seems comparable to putting a Yanni song on the soundtrack to Hostel.

39. Jurassic 5 – “What’s Golden.” I think their best song was 1998’s “Without a Doubt” – if they’d stuck with that slightly harder sound, they might have found a more consistent audience – but this was the high point of their recordings after that debut disc.

38. The Music – “Freedom Fighters.” Another ’70s-influenced band – that huge guitar riff just fills your ears, and I think the lack of a singable chorus hurt their chances on this side of the pond. “Breakin’” gets an honorable mention, but that flopped here as well, and they have possibly the least radio-friendly band name since Pussy Galore.

37. Carbon Leaf – “The Boxer.” Done right, rock tinged with Irish folk music is among my favorite styles of music. To the ring, to the right.

36. Velvet Revolver – “Slither“. I admit it – hearing this for the first time, I went right back to ’87 and the first time I heard Appetite for Destruction. Of course, back in ’87 it blew my ears off, while in 2004 it was a little quaint.

35. Mute Math – “Typical.” Too clever by half? Mute Math seems to have a reputation as a brilliant band, and the whole playing-backwards trick was pretty cool, but “I know there’s got to be another level/Somewhere closer to the other side” might as well be a Backstreet Boys lyric. Good thing the hook in the chorus is so catchy.

34. Stereophonics – “Have A Nice Day.” Yes, I know “Dakota” was far more successful on both sides of the Atlantic, but having listened to Stereophonics’ earlier output, I felt like I’d heard “Dakota” too many times before – “The Bartender And The Thief” is a similar yet better song in the same pseudo-punk vein, and “Local Boy In The Photograph
is better but less punk-ish, although both were released too early for this list. “Have a Nice Day” is a slower, folkier number based on the cliched provincial cab driver met by the band – this one in San Francisco, as the story goes – but I’ll give Kelly Jones credit for a more detailed picture of the driver’s attitude and for putting such a unique stamp on the song with his raspy vocals. Come to think of it, I need to reload all my Stereophonics tracks on to my iPod.

33. White Stripes – “Seven Nation Army.” Great song, but overplayed to the point where I can still only take it in limited doses. One of the top intro bass lines in rock history.

32. Morningwood – “Nth Degree.” Surprised this never caught on as a “get amped” song at sporting events. Because it … gets you amped. I still have no idea what the shrieking voice says in the chorus.

31. Silversun Pickups – “Lazy Eye.” How long before we brand these guys one-hit wonders? And am I the only one who wasn’t sure if the lead singer was male or female? Great song in the single edit, but the outro to the album track is just late-60s wanking, and I doubt there’s been a bigger letdown for me when learning the actual lyrics to any song. “That same old decent lazy-eye?” Uh, okay.

30. Keane – “Somewhere Only We Know.” And the first track on their next album, “Spiralling,” was great and much more uptempo, which deked me into buying the entire thing only to discover that it sucked. But “Somewhere” is a beautiful lament along the lines of Coldplay’s “Trouble,” but with more urgency and less dirge.

29. Matt & Kim – “Daylight.” I think this is the newest (by release date) song on the list, although that’s a function of my attempt to avoid excessive recent-ism in putting the top 40 together. It’s the best White Stripes song not written or recorded by the White Stripes.

28. Coldplay – “In My Place.” I understand that “Clocks” is The Hit for these guys, but I was burned out on that song within a year, even before the Jays used it in a video montage at the end of the 2003 season to pay tribute to Roy Halladay’s (presumed, at the time) Cy Young-winning performance. I heard this song at a Coldplay concert from their first tour, and that opening riff made it the most memorable song of the night, even though I’d never heard it before.

27. Ian Brown – “Upside Down.” I’m not sure I would have even discovered this if it wasn’t by the former lead singer of the Stone Roses, since it garnered no airplay that I know of in the U.S. and is probably the most bizarre song on the list, with no percussion and an incongruous trumpet solo. Then again, Brown’s solo stuff has all been weird and compelling, so while this isn’t as good as “Set My Baby Free,” it’s his best song of the decade.

26. Wolfmother – “Joker And The Thief.” If you’re into old-school guitar rock at all, you had to like this song, right? The opening lick was hypnotic, and the producer tweaked every bit for maximum bombast. Sort of a guy’s guy song. I would have been surprised if they’d ever cooked up anything close to this good again.

25. Gnarls Barkley – “Crazy.” Cee-Lo’s “Closet Freak,” from his 2002 solo debut, gets an honorable mention here, too. Of course, “Crazy” ended up massively overplayed, and at this point I could stand a six-month break from it.

24. Flogging Molly – “Float.” I’ve mentioned this one before – I’m something of a sucker for Irish folk songs or, as with “Float,” songs that bring that sound forward into a sort of folk-rock hybrid. Few do it well and this, to me, is the pinnacle.

23. Chemical Brothers featuring Q-Tip, “Galvanize.” And let me just state for the record that I was all over this song a year before Budweiser stuck it on their commercials. There really is no justification for using a song this good to advertise a beer that bad.

22. Interpol – “Slow Hands.” This was the first Interpol song that didn’t sound to me like a blatant Joy Division ripoff (not that that’s even a bad thing, as there are forty million worse bands to rip off than JD), and also showed their deft hand at manipulating tempo and layering to create a full, textured song with a cathartic release in the final chorus.

21. The Stills – “Still In Love Song.” I thought these guys were supposed to be the next big thing, but this turned out to be their only … I can’t quite call it a hit. But the mix of sneer and despair in the vocals and the plaintive lead guitar line before each verse gave the song a Smiths vibe without a needless Morrissey impersonation.

20. Doves – “Words.” Either that main guitar riff hooks you on the first listen, or it annoys the hell out of you and you can’t get it out of your head for weeks. Needless to say I’m in group one, and the added layering as the song goes on just builds a tension that’s only broken by the quieter counterpoint in each chorus.

19. Sambassadeur – “Kate.” If the Kings of Convenience had been right and quiet really was the new loud, the Swedish band Sambassadeur would have been huge. As it was, they had to settle for royalties from a Payless Shoes commercial and a spot on my iPod. The song would be unbearably twee if it wasn’t for the lead singer’s slightly smoky voice and faint Swedish accent.

18. The Hives – “Hate To Say I Told You So.” The skinny ties and matching outfits were stupid, but they churned out a few memorable bone-crunchers, including this song and “Walk Idiot Walk.”

17. The Soundtrack of Our Lives – “Sister Surround.” I thought their Behind the Music album would cross over, but their sound was probably 25 years late and five years early, as ’70s guitar rock seemed to make a comeback at the end of the decade with songs like Wolfmother’s entry on the list.

16. Gorillaz – “19-2000 (Soulchild Remix).” The best fake band ever? I suppose an angry Rutles fan will show up in the comments to flame me. The hip pick for decade-end lists is “Feel Good Inc.,” another great song and one boosted by De La Soul’s best output since 3 Feet High and Rising, but this remix of an otherwise unremarkable song from Gorillaz’ debut has been on my main playlist since I first entered the digital music player world five or six years ago.

15. White Stripes – “Icky Thump.” I don’t generally get excited about politically-themed lyrics, but these were spot-on, in large part because Jack White picked a topic you could actually address in three minutes of words. Oh, and the song rocks.

14. The Klaxons – “Golden Skans.” Nu-rave died fast, yet the Klaxons, one of its leading lights, lived on. Good luck getting the chorus out of your head.

13. Modest Mouse – “Dashboard.” Johnny Marr’s revenge. I also think of this as the great pop song the Pixies never made.

12. Mike Doughty – “Looking At The World From The Bottom Of A Well.” A bouncy, sing-along (and ironic) track inspired by one of my favorite novels. The whole album, Haughty Melodic (an anagram of “Michael Doughty”), was excellent, although this was clearly the best track. I still miss Soul Coughing.

11. Queens of the Stone Age – “The Lost Art Of Keeping A Secret.” “No One Knows” is a great song, but nothing could top this sinister groove from their first album, Rated R, the perfect marriage of a subtle melody and detuned guitars.

10. Outkast – “Hey Ya!.” The best Prince song by an artist other than Prince.

9. Crystal Method – “Name Of The Game.” Not normally my style of music, but guitar riffs from Tom Morello and a contribution from a member of underground rap group Styles of Beyond plus a driving beat make for a hell of a driving or workout song.

8. Franz Ferdinand – “Take Me Out.” Requires no explanation, I assume.

7. The Dandy Warhols – “Bohemian Like You.” A bit forgotten as the music scene changed over the course of the decade, but it’s a catchy song dripping with snark aimed at the indie music scene.

6. White Stripes – “The Denial Twist.” Not their usual straight-ahead rocker, but they manage to update a Motown-esque sound into their minimalist musical style with plenty of wordplay in the lyrics. I probably could have put another half-dozen White Stripes songs on this list without much of a stretch.

5. Roots featuring Musiq – “Break You Off.” The best hip-hop song of the decade, assuming you accept it as hip-hop instead of R&B or soul or just … great music.

4. Arctic Monkeys – “I Bet You Look Good On The Dancefloor.” Still like this song as much now as when I first heard it, if not more. Spawned dozens of imitators, none of which produced a song this good.

3. Coldplay – “Viva La Vida.” Brilliant track from a brilliant album. I do wish these idiots hadn’t made themselves soft-rock icons with XY, because it has hurt their credibility as artists trying to expand the boundaries of pop (or pop/rock) music.

2. Kaiser Chiefs – “I Predict A Riot.” They did have another minor success with “Ruby,” but I think they’re really destined to go down as one of rock’s greatest one-hit wonders with this bizarre, relentless song that pairs despairing lyrics with an upbeat track.

1. Doves – “Caught By The River.” (video, although it’s the edited version) My favorite track by my favorite band, the soaring end to The Last Broadcast. Heavy U2 influence on the guitar interludes between verses. The fire that destroyed Sub Sub’s recording studio was probably the greatest conflagration in music history.

Comments

  1. WOW KLaw, I hold you in very high esteem, and this impressive list jumps that up a bit. I really can’t argue with much of anything here. I love the Roots being on here, my favorite band, and I didn’t figure they were your style. Well done.

  2. Great list! Saw Doughty at the Fillmore in San Fran a few years ago. Probably one of the best shows I have ever seen.

  3. Silversun Pickups a one hit wonder? They have 3 other top 20 modern rock songs, 2 of which are top 5 and 1 (Panic Switch) which went to #1.

  4. I’m with you on the Stills. Still In Love was great, Rememberese was a bit of a letdown but gave you just enough hope to think they’d come back and be great, and then they didn’t.

  5. You must be an NME reader 🙂

    Caught by the River is a great song, it’s in my top three by Doves.

  6. Some of my favorite (very rudimentary process of sorting by playcount on itunes)

    Desire – Ryan Adams
    Circles – Bob Mould
    Bleeding Heart Show – New Pornographers
    Everybody Choose Sides – Wrens
    Deep Red Bells – Neko Case
    He War – Cat Power
    I Turn My Camera On – Spoon
    Evil – Interpol
    One with the Freaks – Notwist
    Party Crashers – Radio 4
    Carry Me Ohio – Sun Kil Moon
    Counting Down the Hours – Ted Leo

  7. Awesome list. “Daylight” as a kind of Modest Mouse feel to it I think. At least that’s what popped into my head first.

  8. You were not the only one confused about the SSPU’s lead singer’s gender.

    A few favorites of mine from the past decade according to playcount:
    Minus the Bear, “Drilling”
    The Appleseed Cast, “Blind Man’s Arrow”
    “We Are Only” by Taking Pictures
    The Forms, “Knowledge In Hand”
    The Dismemberment Plan, “Ellen and Ben”
    The Sexy Accident, “Morning Pales”
    Shiner, “Andalusia”
    Audioslave, “Cochise”
    Faraquet, “Carefully Planned” and “Cut Self Not”
    Fourth Rotor, “Vacuum” (available for free at their website…Plain is 14:29)
    Diane Ziegler, “Forgiveness” (singer/songwriter)
    Tommy Emmanuel, “The Robin” (acoustic soloist)
    Foo Fighters, “Times Like These”
    STP, “Transmissions from a Lonely Room”
    Medications, “Safe and Sorry”
    Bottomless Pit, “The Cardinal Movements”
    Chick Corea New Trio, “Fingerprints” (jazz)
    John Scofield, “I’ll Catch You” (jazz)
    Dave Glenn, “Lost in the Sun” (jazz…and from an album about baseball!)
    Something by Death Cab for Cutie (perhaps “Soul Meets Body” or “The New Year”)

  9. KPitkin – did he play “Fire Truck?” That’s a Doughty staple.

    Matt: No one is going to remember “Panic Switch” in ten years. Or five.

  10. I don’t think Kaiser Chiefs qualify as one hit wonders given how many records they sell in the UK. Their first release is a really good Blur album, and “I Predict a Riot” isn’t even the best song on it. It’s too bad they haven’t been able to follow it up.

    “Start Wearing Purple” by Gogol Bordello would be my highest ranking song missing from your list.

  11. Great list. Being a Boston expatriate – I am having big time WFNX flashbacks. A little surprised not to see any Strokes or Wilco on the list, but some good out of left field choices.

    By the way, some deejay WFNX did a great kazoo version of Seven Nation Army back in the day…

  12. “And am I the only one who wasn’t sure if the lead singer was male or female?”

    No, you are not, Keith.

  13. Call Me On Your Way Back Home- Ryan Adams. Released in the first year of the decade, nothing else came close for me. I’ve heard it at least 500 times and it still kills me. “Honey I was just a kid/ Bubblegum on my shoe”

  14. Nice list, Keith. Love the inclusion of the Roots, as well as “Lazy Eye” and “Hey Ya”. IMHO, you missed the best Modest Mouse song: “Gravity Rides Everything”.

    Anyway, the best song of each of the last four years (lyrics, creativity, music, etc.):
    2006 – The Shins – Sleeping Lessons
    2007 – Wilco – Impossible Germany
    2008 – Wolf Parade – Fine Young Cannibals
    2009 – Animal Collective – My Girls

    Sad to not see any of those on the list – but maybe you’ve never heard them!

  15. Oh my gosh!! “Sister Surround”! I thought I was the only one in the world who was aware of this song. I am flat-out amazed to see it mentioned anywhere, by anyone.

  16. I have never gotten into Wilco. I know they’ve been critical darlings since Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, but they do nothing for me.

    Trevor – I bought the Chiefs’ first album and nothing touched “Riot” for me. “Oh My God” was fair, but closer to filler than a hit, and that was my #2 song on the disc.

    Aiden – definitely haven’t heard the last two.

    Mike – considered Spoon, several songs I liked this decade but nothing strongly enough for the list.

    A follower on Twitter asked about Arcade Fire. Like Spoon, had some songs I liked, and “Neighborhood #3 (Power Out)” was one of the last cuts, with “Keep the Car Running” also a consideration. But they didn’t have staying power – six months after I added them, I was skipping them on the playlist.

  17. @Aiden – If I had to guess artists least likely to be on Keith’s top 40, I would put Animal Collective there. “My Girls” is a great song though.

    @keith I’ll take Interpol doing a modern take on Joy Division over Interpol doing their own thing any day. I know you are a singles guy, but what are some of your favorite non-single tracks?

  18. I’m wondering about the lack of Radiohead. Not a fan?

  19. I’m shocked that there is not ONE song from The Killers on this list. It is not plausible to have a decade list without one song from those guys. I also don’t understand what you see in “Break you off” as the best hip hop song of the decade. It doesn’t stand out to me, but to each his own.

  20. Wickethewok – I don’t know…Keith seems pretty diverse in his taste and has a couple songs on his list where he admits to them not being his style. I’ve kind of become obsessed with Animal Collective over the past year – they are so much more than a “hipster/stoner” band. They usually have excellent lyrics and are extremely creative. I often hate their songs the first time I listen (ex. “For Reverend Green”, “Grass”) and fall in love after a few more – it’s hard to explain.

    Sad to not see any Spoon or Arcade Fire make it, Keith! How close was Tokyo Police Club – Your English is Good? I remember you suggested it a while back – excellent song.

    How could I forget not to recommend this 9 minute gem: Built to Spill – Goin’ Against Your Mind. One of my favorite guitar riffs ever.

    A few more before I finally shut up:
    Cold War Kids – Tell Me in the Morning
    Nada Surf – Blizzard of ’77
    Telekinesis – Coast of Carolina

    and what is probably the best rap song of the decade (rap is pretty much all I listened to back around 5 years ago in high school):
    Deltron 3030 – 3030

  21. So you’re a fan of British alternative and you don’t have anything from Muse on here? Interesting.

  22. This was a lot of fun to read. I’m already working on a Top 75 Albums of the 2000s list, and now I’m inclined to do something involving songs.

    A few that come to mind:

    “Rebellion (Lies)”-The Arcade Fire
    “You Can Make Him Like You”-The Hold Steady
    “Illinois”-Sufjan Stevens
    “Various Disgraces”-The Blam
    “Idioteque”-Radiohead
    “Trials and Tribulations”-LCD Soundsystem
    “Poison Oak”-Bright Eyes
    “1901”-Phoenix
    “Young Hearts Spark Fire”-Japandroids
    “Dancing Choose”-TV On the Radio

  23. Keith yes he did! He also did an awesome rendition of the “Gambler”

  24. WOW! “Sister Surround” is a blast from the past. That was a song on an MLB Xbox game. Haven’t heard it in years. Still a great jam.

  25. Radiohead: Loved The Bends and, of course, OK Computer. They’d have 4-5 songs on a similar list of the 1990s. But I have never really embraced their new sound. I liked “Optimistic” and “Knives Out” but didn’t seriously consider either for this ranking.

    Killers: “Somebody Told Me” was wildly overplayed. “Mr. Brightside” was fair. That’s about it for them – their second album was a pretentious, bloated mess.

    Aiden: Love “Your English is Good” but I only heard it for the first time in late May and felt like it was too recent for me to know if it could stand the test of time. I toyed with adding LCD Soundsystem’s “Daft Punk is Playing…” but I think I like that song more as a novelty hit than something I’d listen to all the time.

  26. I have to say, I am pretty impressed with this list also. Way to represent the best band from the aughts (White Stripes). And no Killers! Thanks You!!

    Also, I forgot about The Darkness song. That was a big hit earlier this decade, good work.

  27. Any love for Cage the Elephant or Phoenix? They haven’t been around for very long so the staying power part of your criteria is probably incomplete, but I’d guess a few tracks will be hanging around for some time.

    As far as hiphop, I can’t see not including anything off of Aesop Rock’s Labor Days or Float albums. Have you heard either of those?

  28. I was surprised to see no songs from Radiohead or Muse. Especially, if you enjoy artists from the British music scene.

  29. I like that Kaiser Chiers was so high on the list but my preferred song by them is ‘Never Miss a Beat’. Also, considering all the music on here I’m surprised Muse didn’t make the list. Great band in my opinion and I liked most of the bands on this list so they definitely should be in there somewhere.

  30. Rated R is QOTSA’s second album. Unfortunately, their self-titled debut is out of print.

  31. question for Keith, then a few comments:

    “Spawned dozens of imitators, none of which produced a song this good.” Heard of Arctic Monkeys, but couldn’t pick their song out of a lineup. After hearing your pick, no “imitators” come to mind (as a direct result of them). Care to name a few?

    Comments:
    this is Keith’s “favorites” list; it’s always humorous to read people saying they’re surprised song A or song B are not on it. that being said, I am surprised no Raconteurs songs made the list considering his affection for the Stripes.

    lots of singles and mainstream hits on here. Considering how concentrated Keith’s tastes are, I expected to see more b-sides on here. Then again, maybe he’s more of a “buy the song not the album” guy, which I vaguely recall him posting before on the dish.

    I wonder if he revisits this list in a year, would any other 2009 songs make the list as they’ve survived the “recentness” hurdle? Personally, I’ll need another year to decide if any Them Crooked Vultures (for example) would make my “Best of 2000’s” list.

  32. A second nod for Raconteurs. Broken Boy Soldier was one of the best rock albums of the decade. Consolers of the Lonely, the follow-up, was not.

  33. Rob H: Wombats, Little Man Tate, Milburn come to mind. I’m sure there are plenty of others that I’m forgetting or just didn’t hear.

    Raconteurs didn’t do it for me. “Old Enough,” from their second album, is probably my favorite track by them.

  34. “Silversun Pickups a one hit wonder? They have 3 other top 20 modern rock songs, 2 of which are top 5 and 1 (Panic Switch) which went to #1.”

    As much as I loathe the “everything sounds the same” criticism of artists … well … sometimes it fits.

    If I’m building my best of ESPN, I’ll take Law’s sports picks but Shirley’s music picks. Any other straight dude who loves Tegan & Sara is going to be tough to beat.

  35. Did T&S do anything worthwhile beyond “Walking With a Ghost?”

  36. “Desire – Ryan Adams”

    “Call Me On Your Way Back Home- Ryan Adams”

    Typical Keith Law, anti-Cardinal bias.

  37. “Did T&S do anything worthwhile beyond “Walking With a Ghost?”

    I’ve loved the last two albums. The 2009 release (“Sainthood”) is great from the 3rd listen on.

  38. I’m an album guy, not a singles guy so I’m doing my top 9 of the last 3 years of the decade (as that time period coincides with switching to a job that allowed streaming radio) …

    Andrew Bird – “Armchair Apocrypha” (2007)
    The National – “Boxer” (2007)
    Okkervil River – “The Stage Names” (2007)
    Sea Wolf – “Leaves in the River” (2007)
    Bon Iver – “For Emma, Forever Ago” (2008)
    Joseph Arthur – “Temporary People” (2008)
    Passion Pit – “Manners” (2009)
    Phoenix – “Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix” (2009)
    Tegan & Sara – “Sainthood” (2009)

  39. I havent looked at the other comments but, I’m pretty sure “Rated R” was the second QOTSA album, after the self titled debut.

    How could you leave off “Feel Good Hit Of The Summer”? That title alone is awesome.

  40. Just read he comments. Really, the self tited debut is out of print? I have the original, I can burn a copy and send it to people, it they want.

  41. Uh-oh. Paging August 2009 …

  42. Forgive me for being naive, but how does an album go out of print? Can’t they just sell digital copies? It’s not like they literally have to make copies and ship them to stores.

    I wish the checks Oliver Perez receives went out of print. K-Rod too.

  43. Regarding The Killers, I would agree about “Somebody Told Me” being overplayed. However, Mr. Brigthtside is one of my favorite songs ever. If you haven’t heard “Read My Mind” then I’d highly recommend that one too. Those two should warrant consideration for any decade list.

  44. Little known fact: there is no bass in “Seven Nation Army”. Strange, but true.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seven_Nation_Army

  45. The Stills disappeared? Wait, their last album was huge in Canada and got a bunch of play (and was probably their best album). They are still big here at least!

  46. I think you forgot M.I.A.’s paper planes for the simple fact it is the rap song that every “Gansta Rapper” wished they wrote.

  47. Ernie

    Yes, it’s out of print. There are still a few copies here and there though. The last three copies on Amazon are going for $130

    http://bit.ly/51PwcL

  48. Mike T,

    HOLY CRAP! I mean, its a good album, but its not that good. I like the bass line in”Give The Mule What He Wants”.

  49. No Radiohead or Bon Iver… seriously? “Viva la vida” or whatever that post-Coldplay-selling-out song is called made it, but “Idioteque” did not? I would have given you “Green Eyes” by Coldplay, but nothing off of the new CD.

    Your list reminds me of something… hmm… like something Rob Gordon would have come up with. I’m surprised you didn’t go with a “Top 5 Songs of the Decade” list. 😛

  50. J. Yirinec: This is a favorites list. It’s not a critical ranking. I haven’t loved anything that Radiohead has done post-OK Computer, ergo, they don’t make the list. Stumping for a particular song that I already know sort of misses the point.