Strawberry-Rhubarb Crisp.

I’ve got a short piece up on Georgia Tech infielder Derek Dietrich, who’ll be a consideration for the first round next year..

My recipes are usually precise based on multiple attempts to make a dish, but this one is an exception, since I threw it together based in part on what I had left of ten pounds of strawberries and about a pound of rhubarb. The amounts in the fruit base are approximate, and the quantity of sugar you use is going to depend on how sweet your strawberries are. The result was a huge hit, and I thought it was better than the damn good strawberry-rhubarb pie I made on Thursday morning. Next time I do this, I’ll weigh the topping ingredients and I’ll revise it.

Fruit base:
1 pound strawberries, hulled and sliced in half
1/3-1/2 pound rhubarb, chopped into inch-long pieces
Roughly 1/2 cup sugar, depending on the sweetness of your strawberries
1 Tbsp rum, preferably black or dark
1/2 tsp vanilla extract
1-2 tsp fresh lemon juice
3-4 tsp arrowroot or corn starch
Pinch salt

Crisp topping:
1/2 stick (1/4 cup) butter, softened
3/4 cups flour
3/4 cups dark brown sugar, packed*
1/2 cup plus 2 Tbsp rolled oats
3/4 tsp cinnamon
1/8 tsp freshly grated nutmeg
Pinch freshly ground cloves
1 1/2 Tbsp vegetable/canola oil**
1/4 tsp salt

* I used half muscovado, a natural dark brown sugar that has a pronounced molasses taste, and half standard brown sugar.
** Anything that’s neutral in flavor would work here. Ergo, not olive oil.

Preheat your oven to 375 degrees.

1. Toss all fruit base ingredients together in a large bowl or directly in the baking dish and set aside for 10-15 minutes. This is really a pie filling, although most strawberry-rhubarb pies go for a 1:1 ratio of fruits, while I prefer a 3:1 ratio here, so that the strawberries are the star and the rhubarb is justa backup player.

2. Cut the butter into 1/2″ pieces and combine all crisp topping ingredients together in a large bowl. With your fingertips – or, if you’re a complete wuss, a pastry-cutter or two knives – work the butter into the remaining ingredients until it’s combined but not homogenous, with large clumps of dry ingredients around pieces of butter.

3. Move the fruit mixture into the baking dish of your choice – I used an 11x9x2 corningware dish – and top with the crumb mixture, covering the entire surface. (The fruit mixture will bubble through and submerge parts of the topping, creating a pan-dowdy-like effect.) Bake for about 30 minutes and check the dish. You’re looking for a nicely browned top and thick juices bubbling up from the fruit mixture. If you don’t have those two things happening, drop the temperature to 325 degrees and bake until it’s done. (Mine was done at 30 minutes.) Allow to cool to room temperature or close to it so that the starch/liquid mixture can set, after which you can reheat it if you want to eat it warm.

Comments

  1. How do you “hull” a strawberry?

  2. I pinch the leaves off, insert a paring knife at the edge of the white hull, then rotate the strawberry to remove a cone-shaped piece, which usually gets the entire hull and little to none of the red flesh. Alton Brown uses a star-shaped pastry tip, but I found this was a complete PITA to clean after each berry. There is also a device known as a strawberry huller or strawberry tweaker, which is made by idiots for idiots and should not be in your kitchen.

  3. Thanks. Since you’re ultimately halving the strawberries out, could you scoop the hull out post-cut? Or is this sloppier?

  4. I made strawberry ice cream today and therefore hulled an s-load of strawberries. I am lazy and skipped the pinching leaves off part and just used the paring knife as Keith described. I can verify that cutting the berry in half first, while no sloppier, is slower. Once you get used to your paring motion, you can move through them quickly. Sure, maybe I have tiny slices all over my left thumb, but no pain, no gain. The gain was delicious.

  5. Pinching the leaves off does two things – it makes it easier to see exactly where to insert the knife, and it reduces the chances that you’ll get leaves into your finished product. (They don’t taste very good, and consumed in quantity they have a laxative effect.)

    I can pare two pounds in about ten minutes, and I think halving before paring would double the work. As stack said, you develop muscle memory pretty quickly and it becomes rote. Just don’t move the knife – only the berry – when hulling and you won’t get hurt.

  6. Jen and I have a pound of rhubarb from our first CSA delivery of the spring and have been meaning to do something with it … it was clearly fate that I found this recipe. We may even let Ian try some.

    I know what you’re saying with the Alton pastry tip, but I remember trying it once and just blowing the hulled berry bits into a bowl.

  7. Thank you for the recipe Keith, I have had no luck trying to track down a good straw. & rhubarb pie. Can the muscavado be substituted for brown suger in all recipes? Does it effect the baking, and how strong is the molasses taste that is created?

  8. Hey Keith,

    Think I could sub out th e straw/rhu mixture for blueberries (of which I currently have an abundance)? I’m looking for a recipe wouldn’t require me to make pie crust, and was leaning towards a buckle.

    However, I think this may be easier (and possibly tastier).

  9. I don’t see why not, Chris. You wouldn’t need rhubarb, but I’d recommend more lemon juice or a mix of lemon and lime (blueberries love limes). You could also play with the spices, as blueberries play well with spices like star anise, allspice, and cloves. I’ll give it a shot when we go blueberry picking in early July.

  10. Grant – muscovado can be swapped in for dark brown sugar. It’s wetter and has a stronger flavor; I found that in chocolate chip cookies, it became a dominant flavor when used in place of all of the dark brown sugar.

  11. Thanks, Keith.

    It’s on the cooling rack now. I went with about 5 cups of blueberries and baked it in a casserole dish roughly 8×8 to 9×9-ish.

    Went with roughly your suggested amount lemon juice plus about 1 tbsp. of lime juice (didn’t measure either, just an estimate). I also upped the sugar some to make up for the tartness of the berries.

    I’ll let you know how it actually tastes when it’s not so molten.

  12. I think AB said something along the lines of “I think the fact that rhubarb and strawberries come into season together is proof enough that God exists for me”.

    Can’t argue with that. I could eat this crisp for days on end.

  13. the wife and I just checked out five guys for the first time. we were highly skeptical anything could rival in n out. we concluded that in n out was better but couldn’t fault one for believing differently.

  14. Following up on the blueberry crisp:

    – I liked the crisp topping quite a bit.
    – Should NOT have upped the sugar in the blueberry mixture, even with the added lime juice. Perhaps the berries were sweeter than I have been getting (they were the first NJ blueberries I’ve had this season).
    – Should have used more tapioca. Turned out a little more runny than I would have liked. There’s actually enough of leftover sauce that I reduced it in a pot to use as an ice cream topping. Again, may be a result of better quality berries than I’ve been using.
    – Still like it better than making a pie crust.

  15. Keith, you’ve answered this before, but I forgot to write it down. What are the best
    “teach yourself” cookbooks? Thanks!

  16. Made this last night, minus the rum. Tasted amazing, althought it was REALLY sweet. Thanks!

  17. I think the real variable is the strawberries. I got some very ripe ones, cut the sugar to about 1/3 cup, and then found the finished crisp wasn’t sweet enough. Go figure.

    Also, check my cookbooks for newbies post.

  18. Keith, thanks for the book recommendations. I bought all 3 for myself and one as a gift -Amazon.com should give you a commission.

    I met Tim Kurkjian the other day in DC, and he told some funny stories about a few ESPN guys who (1) knows the score of each Phillies game by memory over a 15 year (?) period and (2) can describe what each player’s baseball card looks like over a 10 year period. Thought that was awesome/weird.