Atlanta eats.

On the culinary front, Atlanta was disappointing – five restaurants, the best of which was one I’ve been to many times, and two of which were big disappointments.

The Flying Biscuit is a bit of a local legend, apparently, but I’d been warned that it wasn’t as good as it was in its heyday. Given how I feel about biscuits, though, I thought it was worth a shot, especially since the one thing I expected them to still do well was the food item that appears in their name. No such luck: The biscuit was tasteless and even a bit flat, with a dry exterior and a doughy interior. Nothing else on the plate stood out, and I was a bit put off by the fact that the menu includes no pork products of any kind. It’s breakfast, kids. Bacon comes from a pig. Don’t insult me by trying to make it out of poultry.

On the other hand, the biscuits at the Silver Skillet, over by Georgia Tech, were excellent – light, fluffy, buttery (maybe a bit too much so – seriously, just brush the tops, don’t douse them), and you get two of them with your eggs and pork product. The eggs (scrambled) were nicely cooked as well. Some other online reviewers seem to like the décor, but I found it kitschy, and they get a point or two off for serving food-service tea.

Two separate rankings (one by CitySearch) put Williamson Bros. Bar-B-Q at the top of Atlanta-area barbecue joints … which doesn’t say much for Atlanta-area barbecue. (J.C. Bradbury, of Sabernomics blogging fame, told me later that day that Atlanta has no good ‘cue. Figures.) I went with a combo plate – ribs (which turned out to be spare ribs), pulled pork, fried okra, BBQ beans, and a slice of toast. The ribs were so tough that I gave up after one. The pulled pork was better, nice and moist, but really light on flavor; they get bonus points for including some end bits in the mix. The okra was greasy, and the batter didn’t include the traditional cornmeal. The BBQ beans were actually quite good, with a fruity flavor I couldn’t identify (I’m thinking apple juice, but I’m not sure). I’d go back for a plate of pulled pork or a sandwich, but a Q place that can’t do ribs doesn’t belong at the top of any rankings.

Back over by Georgia Tech, I walked from the park (a top-notch college facility) up to the Tin Drum Asia Café, which theoretically is a quick food option. I say theoretically because it took over 20 minutes from when I placed my order for me to get my very simple lunch, which I don’t believe they started making until I complained that it was taking so long. To make matters worse, the food was nothing special: The coconut soup with chicken (tom kha gai) was bland, and the shrimp tempura “drumroll” (a couple of fried shrimp with avocado, tomato, and a honey-miso dressing on a small roti) was greasy. I can see why the student body likes it, though – all that plus a bottle of water was under $10.

Finally, the best meal I had on the trip was an old standby: Annie’s Thai Castle in Buckhead, which I’ve been visiting on trips to Atlanta for about twelve years now, and it’s still as good today as it was when my friend Steve first took me there. Their pad prik with beef was the highlight of this visit – spicy but not incendiary, with extremely tender strips of beef – and their pad thai is always solid. We also had their chicken with yellow curry, which was very good, not too sweet the way a lot of places serve it. You also get plenty of food at Annie’s, which is important, since I was eating with a scout who has two hollow legs.

Comments

  1. I never leave Atlanta without at least one visit to the Buckhead Diner, if I can help it. I’ve yet to be disappointed (other than by the long waits).

  2. Tim O'Malley

    Keith, big mistake in Atlanta on your BBQ choice

    Two places:

    Fat Matt’s Rib Shack on Piedmont

    PiG N Chick on Roswell Road north of Buckhead

    Live and learn

    Also: Bankok Thyme (about 1 block north of Pig N Chick) dwarfs Annie’s Thai Castle

  3. Williamson Bros. Bar-B-Q is not good at all. Next time in the ATL, try Sam and Dave’s in Marietta (not too far from Williamson Bros.), Pig and Chick on Roswell Road, and the Swallow at the Hollow in downtown Roswell.

    The Flying Biscuit is overrated and resting on past laurels. Silver Skillet was an excellent choice. Also try Java Jive on Ponce de Leon and the Highlands Bakery on North Highlands Street for good breakfast.

    As far as Thai, you have to do Tamarind Seed at the corner of 14th Street and Peachtree Street in Colony Square.

    And finally for slightly more upscale dining, try Shaun’s in Inman Park on Egdewood Dr and Wisteria on North Highlands; both places are excellent.

    Don’t touch the sushi here, it sucks! 🙂

    Give Atlanta another chance, we have good food to offer!

  4. Thanks, guys. That’s just the sort of feedback I was looking for when I started the blog. The only place of all of those rec’s I’ve been to is the Buckhead Diner, been at least twice, good stuff. I’m sure I’ll be back to the ATL, if not for the Braves this year then to see some HS kids in the spring.

  5. you’re welcome keith! please come down to see teixeira and the braves catch the mets, and the baseball factory out here in cobb county (nw atl burbs, home of corey patterson, jeremy hermida, et al…)

    another suggestion, for lunch, carver’s country kitchen. it’s a dump, but has the best southern cooking ever!

  6. Keith,

    I went to GT a few years back and still dream about Fat Matts Rib Shack. They serve a local beer out of Athens, GA that is really good (Terrapin). When I travel back to Atl. I go out of my way to sit outside with a book, beans, and pulled pork. Saturday night is kinda crazy with a live band but lunch is pretty laid back.