→ October 4, 2022
→ By

Ready Set Bet.

Ready Set Bet is a raucous betting game that’s great for a larger group, with up to 9 folks able to play at once (and if you have ten, once can serve as the race’s announcer), from John D. Clair, the designer of Mystic Vale, Cubitos, Dead Reckoning, and Space Base. He’s also a Dodgers fan, if memory serves correctly, but regardless, all of his previous games have been more gamers’ games, while Ready Set Bet is much lighter and is more of a party game at heart – but a surprisingly fun one given how common and boring the betting theme can be.

Ready Set Bet involves four horse races, and players will bet in real time, placing their tokens on the giant central board, as someone rolls the dice to move the nine horses along the race track, betting until three horses pass the red line on the track. At the end of each round, all bets are paid off, and some bets require players to pay a penalty if those bets didn’t come through. After the first three rounds, each player gets their choice of two cards to give them an extra power through the rest of the game or a one-time bonus. After four rounds, the player with the most money wins.

The horses are represented by the numbers 4 through 10, plus two more horses that bear two numbers, 2 and 3 as well as 11 and 12. The dice you roll to move the horses are just two regular six-sided dice, so the horses in the middle (6, 7, and 8) have a natural advantage, but in Ready Set Bet, if you roll any total twice in a row other than 7, that horse moves several extra spaces to try to compensate. I’ve had the 4 horse win because I happened to roll it three times in a row, which moved it nine extra spaces and gave it an insurmountable lead.

There are two major tweaks to the common betting-game formula in RSB, both of which work quite well. The board has betting spaces for every horse to win, places, or show, and each space has a multiplier on it to represent the payout if that bet comes off. The multipliers are higher on horses farther away from the middle numbers of 6-8, but many of those bets also have a small penalty if you bet on them and the horse lets you down, although it’s generally just a dollar or two. There are also some betting spaces on the board beyond individual horses – betting that a horse in a certain color group will win, or betting on one of the “unusual scenario” cards that appear in rounds 2-4 that have conditions like one horse winning by a certain amount or at least four horses not getting past the one-quarter mark.

The other big tweak is that once someone places one of their tokens on a betting space, it’s occupied for the remainder of that race. Each player has a set of betting tokens numbered 2, 3, 4, and 5, and with fewer than seven players each player gets a second 3 token. To place a bet, you take one of those tokens and place it on any betting space that isn’t currently occupied. If your horse comes through, you get the value of your token times the multiplier on the betting space. There’s no benefit to keeping any of your tokens, so the incentive is to place them all before the third horse crosses the red line – roughly two-thirds of the way across the race board – and to do so sooner than other players do, since most of the betting spaces are limited to just one token.

I’ve played Ready Set Bet as a player, but also played it with family and served as the dice-roller and announcer, including my niece and nephew, who are now 10 and 6, respectively … and my nephew ended up winning outright, because he just bet big on any horse that got an early lead, and at one point got an extra 7 token by way of one of those end-of-round bonus cards, placing it on a 7x betting space for a horse that won. That points to the game’s accessibility, and the way that a little luck can balance things out. I didn’t expect to like this game all that much given the premise, but the simplicity of play and the way everyone, with folks aged 6 to 75 when I played with family, got into it ended up selling me on the game after all.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With:
→ October 2, 2022
→ By

Music update, September 2022.

Lots of new music in September … but not a lot of great music, I think, even with two extremely strong new albums and a couple of others of note. As always, you can see the Spotify playlist here if you can’t see the widget below.

Kid Kapichi – Super Soaker. Two of my favorite albums of 2022 so far came out in September, including Kid Kapichi’s second album in the last 18 months, Here’s What You Could Have Won, which carries forward the harder-edged rock with Alex Turner-like lyrics but expands their musical palate somewhat, such as adding a guest appearance from Bob Vylan.

The Beths – When You Know You Know. And then there’s The Beths’ third album, Expert in a Dying Field, their best one yet, with more uptempo songs and a more consistent musical throughline over the entire album.

White Lies – Trouble in America. A tremendous track from the bonus edition of As I Try Not to Fall Apart, frankly a better song than several that did make the original LP.

Sports Team – Dig! Another banger from Sports Team, but unusual for them in that the vocals are far more conventional, and clearly play second fiddle to the driving guitar work.

Sprints – Literary Mind. These Dublin punks go a little more pop here, without losing any of their usual intensity, in what I think is their longest song yet.

Courtney Barnett – Words and Guitar. A cover of the Sleater-Kinney song from an upcoming album of covers of the band’s 1997 album Dig Me Out.

John-Allison Weiss – Different Now. This is the first new music from Weiss, who has previously recorded as A.W., since 2017’s “Runaway,” although their indie-pop sound is quite similar even after the five-year hiatus.

Editors – Vibe. Editors just released their seventh album, EBM, their first with Blanck Mass (Benjamin John Power) as a full-time member. The sound across the album is similar to what they’ve shown since their big stylistic shift around 2009-10 to something more electro-noir, with a heavy New Order influence. I also really liked “Karma Climb,” the first single from the record; and “Kiss,” which is great in the sub-4 minute single version but wears out its welcome at 8 minutes on the album.

The Fashion Weak feat. Gruff Rhys – Welsh Words. The debut single from a new Welsh band, with help from Super Furry Animals lead singer Rhys, with hilarious lyrics about songwriting advice from Joan Didion.

Freddie Gibbs feat. Moneybagg Yo – Too Much. Gibbs might be the best active rapper going, certainly in terms of flow and delivery, and just dropped his fifth album, the expansive $oul $old $eparately, on Friday. “Dark Hearted” and “Space Rabbit” are also highlights.

Phoenix feat. Ezra Koenig – Tonight. I like this song despite the intrusion of Vampire Weekend (via Koenig, their twee-voiced lead singer and songwriter).

Jamie xx – KILL DEM. The second new single this year from Jamie xx, whose In Colour was one of the best albums of 2015 and provided two standout tracks of the entire decade in “Loud Places” and “See Saw,” but who hasn’t put out another LP since. His solo work is electronica, but he’s also one of three members of the indie band the xx.

Quicksand – Giving the Past Away. A muscular new track from these post-hardcore icons, left over from the sessions for last year’s album Distant Populations.

Palm – On the Sly. A Philly art-rock outfit that’s been around for a decade, Palm just crossed my radar this month with this new track reminiscent of some of Battles’ better work.

WITCH – Waile. WITCH are legends of Zamrock, a musical style from the sub-Saharan country of Zambia that emerged in the 1970s, and were active from 1972-1984, by the end of which they’d moved away from rock and towards disco. This is a new recording of a song they played live in their heyday but never committed to wax. With the crossover success of Mdou Moctar, I could see WITCH (which stands for We Intend to Cause Havoc!) finding a new audience as they continue to tour.

Wheel – Blood Drinker. I’m a big fan of this Finnish prog-metal outfit, whether it’s their ten-minute, multi-section tracks or tighter radio-friendly ones like this one, primarily because of their guitarwork, both the sound itself and the intricacy of some of their guitar lines. This is the advance single from their upcoming EP Rumination, which follows last year’s full-length album Resident Human.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: , , , , ,
→ October 1, 2022
→ By

Stick to baseball, 10/1/22.

Since my last weekend post, I’ve had three few posts up for subscribers to the Athletic, including my annual column on players I was wrong about, my annual Prospect of the Year column, and a quick scouting take on last weekend’s Future Stars Main Event showcase for the 2023 draft.

For Paste I reviewed the board game Cellulose, from Genius Games, which produces science-themed games that try to be both accurate and educational. It’s definitely the former, but I’m not sure about the latter, as it’s a good worker-placement game that you can play well without getting into a lot of the technical stuff.

On the Keith Law Show this week, my guest was author and sportswriter Will Leitch, who wrote the wonderful 2021 novel How Lucky and who has a new novel coming out in May that you can pre-order here. We discussed his writing, his beloved Cardinals, and the upcoming slate of movies for this fall and winter. You can listen and subscribe via iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher, amazon, or wherever you get your podcasts.

My free email newsletter should return next week. COVID and some travel and other stuff just knocked me for a loop.

And now, the links…

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
→ September 29, 2022
→ By

Neurotribes.

Steve Silberman’s 2015 book Neurotribes: The Legacy of Autism and the Future of Neurodiversity is a history of autism, but one told through anecdotes of people with the neurodevelopmental condition or the scientists who studied it. It’s also an education, and an attempt to set the record straight that we are not, in fact, in the middle of an autism “epidemic,” but that the condition has always existed, even if doctors at those times didn’t realize what they were seeing.

Much of the history of autism is one of tragedy, as people with the condition were often treated as insane, or as imbeciles, and stuck in institutions or otherwise abandoned by their families. The condition was seen as incurable – meaning it was seen as something you’d want to try to cure – and that an autistic child was nothing more than an animal. This view persisted, at least in the west (there’s no discussion here of views of autism outside of the U.S. and Europe), until the early 20th century.

That’s when two researchers working independently* had their Newton/Leibniz moment, as both Leo Kanner, working in the U.S., and Hans Asperger, working in Vienna, both published key papers identifying autism as a condition with a specific, and in both cases narrow, set of symptoms. Asperger’s name has lived on beyond Kanner’s, but at the time, Vienna was under Nazi control, and Kanner’s work and views took precedence on the larger stage.

*I got a kind note from Steve Silberman via Twitter, saying: “The biggest historical scoop in NeuroTribes is that Kanner and Asperger were NOT working independently, but shared two assistants, Anni Weiss and Georg Frankl.”

If you know of Asperger, it’s through the now-deprecated “Asperger’s syndrome,” which has been subsumed into the larger diagnostic term autism spectrum disorder. One of the most enlightening parts of Neurotribes is Silberman’s explanation of that entire process, although its roots are horrifying: Because the Nazis were murdering any children held in institutions for health or mental reasons, Asperger’s work focused on the socially awkward prodigies he found. This spurred the still-extant stereotype of the autistic savant, which was further cemented in the public mind by the film Rain Man, the history of which Silberman details at great length and with significant empathy for everyone involved in the film.

Kanner viewed Asperger much as Newton viewed Leibniz, and we’re all quite a bit the worse for it, as the rivalry meant Kanner worked to “own” the definition of autism for some time. He claimed the disorder (a term still in use in the technical literature) only affected young children – if they were older, they had schizophrenia or something else – and that the cause was parental indifference. The idea of the “refrigerator mother” who failed to love her child enough, thus giving the kid autism, persisted for decades, at least into the 1980s. When that finally started to crumble, parents began looking for other explanations, landing on environmental toxins and, with the help of a fraudster named Andrew Wakefield, vaccines.

All the while, parents and researchers were looking for a cure, in no small part because Kanner’s definition of autism excluded all but the most serious cases. Some attempts were well-intentioned, while others were (and still are) quackery, and even dangerous. There’s still an institution in Massachusetts that uses shock therapy on autistic residents, despite no evidence that it works (and ample evidence that it’s torture). The FDA has had to issue warnings about so-called “miracle mineral solution,” which is bleach by another name, and which Youtube for one has banned but refuses to remove instructional videos about. (MMS does not cure autism, or anything else, but it can kill you.) Silberman gets into some of this, although I think the bleach stuff largely postdates his book.

It took some substantial efforts by later researchers and especially by activist parents to bring about changes. Those parents demanded changes in how the medical establishment viewed and treated their autistic children, and lobbied for changes in the definition of autism so that school districts would be forced to provide accommodations for autistic students who were previously left behind or even told that they had to attend school elsewhere. The passage of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act in 1975 and again in 1990 as well as the Americans with Disabilities Act in 1990 allowed autistic children to stay in public schools and required the districts to provide them with individualized education programs (IEP) to determine what accommodations and modifications the child needs to succeed in school. It shouldn’t have been that hard, but Silberman makes it clear that Kanner’s narrow definition and the stranglehold he had on the definition of autism, helped by a small number of others who seemed to profit from their work with autistic kids, made this process far more difficult.

There’s far more to Neurotribes than just a history, however. Silberman discusses a few notable historical figures who almost certainly were autistic, including chemist and physicist Henry Cavendish, the discoverer of hydrogen; and Nikola Tesla, inventor of an overpriced electric car. (Hold on, I’m getting a note here that that isn’t correct.) Temple Grandin makes several appearances on these pages as well. There’s also a deep dive into the correlation between autistic people and sci-fi fandom, including Claude Degler, a key early figure in spreading the gospel of science fiction (until his views on eugenics caught up with him), and perhaps an autistic person himself. Silberman argues that sci-fi fandom was one of the first safe spaces for autistics, as personality “quirks” were less important than one’s passion for the subject – and perhaps because those quirks were more common among the fan base anyway.

There’s a wealth of information within Neurotribes, even though the book is now seven years old and it seems like the medical community knows even more about autism now than it did then. It’s a well-researched and well-argued work, one that encourages empathy for autistic people but not pity, and if anything gives more respect to Wakefield, the NVIC, and other cranks than they deserve, presenting the views of people who seek to find non-genetic causes for autism fairly before explaining that the evidence says they’re wrong. And Silberman makes it very clear that autism isn’t what history tells us it is, or even what many people probably still think it is, thanks to Rain Man or, worse, Music. It’s a deeply humanistic work of non-fiction, and that alone makes it worth a read.

Next up: Dr. Stephanie Cacioppo’s Wired for Love.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: , , , ,
→ September 19, 2022
→ By

An Immense World.

Ed Yong won the Pulitzer Prize for Explanatory Writing last year for his articles in the Atlantic (not my employer) about the COVID-19 pandemic, which I called way back in May of 2020, over a year before the award announcement. I was already a fan of his work after reading his tremendous first book, I Contain Multitudes, a thoughtful, detailed look at the importance of the microbiome, and how so many of our actions and policies work against our own health because of our fear of bacteria. (He also described the experiment to infect male Aeges aegypti mosquitos with the Wolbachia bacterium, which makes the eggs that result from their mating activity fail to hatch. It has since been used to reduce mosquito populations in areas where dengue fever is endemic.)

Yong’s latest book, An Immense World: How Animal Senses Reveal the Hidden Realms Around Us, is a big departure from anything he’s written before, although he retains both his commitment to scientific accuracy and the sense of wonder that permeated his first book. This time around, he’s exploring an area I would guess most readers have never contemplated: How animals sense the world, often in ways that are beyond the reach of our senses, or even rely on senses that humans don’t have.

Yong begins with some discussion of the erroneous historical view, one that still persists today on a smaller scale, that non-human animals are less cognitively capable than we are, because we have evolved consciousness and they haven’t. It’s a view that fails on its face, as just about everyone who’s been around a dog knows that canines can hear sounds we can’t – hence the dog whistle, at least in its literal sense. It turns out, unsurprisingly, that there are examples across the animal world, and in some cases in other biological kingdoms as well, of senses more powerful than our five senses, and examples beyond those.

One of the best-known colloquial examples, although I would say probably not a well-understood one by laypeople, is echolocation in bats. Bats are nearly blind, but their powers of echolocation, using what we now call sonar to determine not just where objects are around them, but to find food and distinguish, say, something to eat from the leaf on which it’s sitting, involve a mental processing speed that is hard for us to comprehend. And it turns out humans are capable of echolocation as well, although evolution hasn’t advanced our skills in that area to the same extent because we haven’t needed it.

Yong also describes the handful of species that can sense the Earth’s magnetic field, a sense humans do not have at all, to find their way back to the beach where they were born, in the case of some turtles. There are animals and insects that can see parts of the infrared spectrum that we can’t, but there are also substantial portions of the animal kingdom that don’t see the world in the same colors we see – which is why waving a red cape in front of a bull is just a silly tradition, as bulls don’t have the red cones in their eyes to detect that color. Indeed, few animals see the world in the same colors that we do, which comes down to the fact that color isn’t something inherent in nature; it is how our eyes perceive vibrations of molecules in nature, because we have red, green, and blue cones in our retinas that send signals that our brains convert to color. (And some people, almost all women, have a fourth cone, making them “tetrachromats,” which Yong also discusses.) If you don’t have those cones, you see the world completely differently.

Yong ends with what is probably the most important part of An Immense World ­– an examination of how humans are screwing all of this up. You’re probably aware of how climate change and overdevelopment are already threatening habitats around the world. Light pollution threatens many species that rely on natural light sources to find food or shelter, or to migrate; noise pollution interferes with many species’ ability to communicate with each other, to find mates or identify predators. Humanity’s rapid rise in the last 200 years has been an unmitigated disaster for everything else on the planet, and Yong points to even more threats to biodiversity than those we already know about (e.g., those explained in The Sixth Extinction). There are also some examples of species adapting to these changes – birds that have learned to hang out near streetlights to eat the moths attracted to the illumination, for example – but they’re too few to make up for the losses. We have to be the ones to adapt, to live with less light, less noise, less everything, so that we don’t lose any more than we’ve already lost, especially not before we’ve learned more about it.

Also, Ed will be my guest this week on the Keith Law Show. The episode should be up on Tuesday, 9/20.

Next up: Steve Silberman’s Neurotribes: The Legacy of Autism and the Future of Neurodiversity.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: , , , ,
→ September 17, 2022
→ By

Stick to baseball, 9/17/22.

My one new post this week for The Athletic is a scouting notebook looking at some Yankees and Red Sox prospects, including Jasson Dominguez, Yoendrys Gomez, and Cedanne Rafaela. I’ve had to push some things off, as I got sick on Tuesday and it turns out that my COVID number is finally up.

My guest on The Keith Law Show this week was Dr. Justin E.H. Smith, author of the book The Internet Is Not What You Think It Is: A History, A Philosophy, A Warning, which you can buy here on Bookshop.org. You can listen and subscribe via iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher, amazon, or wherever you get your podcasts.

My free email newsletter returned today after a long hiatus, describing my COVID experience so far and linking to a lot of the stuff I’ve written over the last few weeks.

And now, the links…

  • Hasidic private schools in New York City fail to provide even the most basic secular education to students, but have taken in $1 billion in taxpayer money, according to an extensive New York Times investigation. It would appear that various Mayors and Governors have declined to fully examine the issue for fear of alienating the Hasidic voting bloc.
  • Years of investigations by the Kansas City Star and other outlets appear to have resulted in the arrest this week of a former Kansas City, Kansas, detective who stands accused of raping two women, taking money from drug dealers, and framing innocent people. It’s unbelievable how long people were aware of what Roger Golubski was allegedly doing, yet he was able to continue to do it, and even retired from one department and got a job with another.
  • The co-chair of the Michigan state GOP referred to Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg as “a weak little girl.”
  • Fred Franzia, the winemaker behind the popular $2 wines known as Two Buck Chucks, died this week at 79.
  • An Iowa law on restitution for victims of violence means that a woman who, at age 15, killed the man who raped and trafficked her, owes his family $150,000. It is, literally, a law of unintended consequences. A GoFundMe for the woman has raised nearly three times that amount already.
  • Jennifer Rubin writes in the Washington Post that the Christian right is ignoring the biggest threat to their existence: Declining religiosity in younger generations. The younger you are, the less likely you are to identify as Christian, or as religious at all.
  • Noted liberal rag (checks notes) Bloomberg has an op ed arguing that the Texas judicial ruling that companies could decline to cover PrEP treatment for employees takes religious freedom too far.
  • Sagrada: Artisans, the legacy version of the great dice-drafting game Sagrada, is now on Kickstarter and already funded.
  • Age of Inventors, an economic/resource management game from a small Greek publisher, is also on Kickstarter and also funded this week.
  • Dune: War for Arrakis, an asymmetrical area-control game pitting the houses Atreides and Harkonnen against each other, is also on Kickstarter, and fully funded even with a higher goal. It seems like it’s designed primarily for two players, but with 3 or 4 the extra players control “sub-factions” loyal to one house or the other.
Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
→ September 16, 2022
→ By

Power Failure.

Power Failure is a clever small-box game from Genius Games that rethemes a Taiwanese game called Power On!, taking some of the concepts of the great route-building game Power Grid while including a key message about climate change. Sometimes a game just hits you the right way; Power Failure has just so-so ratings on BGG, for example, and my daughter really didn’t care for it, but I think it’s both clever and fun. It’s great value at $17 or less, as on Amazon or Miniature Market.

Power Failure has two main conceits: You’re building an engine of power plants that you can fire once per turn, with each plant type requiring different fuel (in the form of cards); and building and firing plants usually involves adding carbon tokens to the shared tower in the middle of the table. When that tower falls, it ends the turn of the player who placed the last token on it, and everyone else has to discard a card from their hands, simulating the environmental cost of generating energy, especially through dirtier forms like coal and natural gas. At the end of your turn, you can “fire” all your plants of one type, and then use the total power you generated to claim a City card that represents the power demand of one city, which is the only way to gain victory points in the game.

Beyond the tower, this is a hand-management game – you get a hand of cards that include power plants, fuel cards for some of those plants, and special action cards. On every turn, you can take three total actions, which can include selecting a card from the common market, playing a card from your hand (building a plant or using a special action card), or firing up all of your plants of a single type. You can do the same action type twice, and in the first two or three rounds you’ll use all three actions to play or draw cards.

There are three main types of power plants in Power Failure, coal, natural gas, and nuclear; plus renewable energy plants that require no fuel and fire automatically on every turn. All power plant types require that you add one carbon token to the tower when you build them. Coal plants require one coal fuel card each to fire them, and you have to add three carbon tokens per plant when you do so. Natural gas plants require one natural gas card each, and you add two tokens per plant when you fire. Nuclear plants don’t add carbon tokens, but you need two separate cards for each plant you fire, one for fuel and one to represent the handling of the nuclear waste. Some renewable plants generate a variable amount of energy, from 0 to 2 units, based on the number showing on the top card on the deck, so you can’t build an entire energy strategy around them, but they can be enough to supplement your other energy sources to get you to a better city card.

Thus your goal is to build an engine of plants, likely concentrating on one type, that you can fuel and fire every other turn or so to try to fulfill a contract on a city card. The catch for coal and nuclear plants, which are cheaper to fire, is that they pollute. For every coal plant you fire, you must add three carbon tokens to the tower, and for every natural gas plant, you must add two. So you might build an engine with three coal plants, which would generate 18 power, enough to claim any contract in the game, but you have to add nine tokens to the tower, doing so one at a time. The tokens are hexagonal wooden pieces about a half-inch thick, and you can stack them flat or vertically, depending on how hard you want to make it for the next player. When the tower falls, your turn ends, you generate no power, and everyone discards a card, after which you reset the tower by starting out with three tokens and play resumes. There’s a little dexterity involved here, which does exclude certain people from playing, unfortunately. I do think the idea is clever because of the way it introduces variability into the mix – every form of power production pollutes at some level, but it’s hard to predict who will actually be the polluter to push the total over some threshold.

Games take 45-60 minutes, and I think it’s good for any age range that can handle the token placement part of the game. There’s some light text required, but it’s manageable for younger players. I also appreciate the color scheme, which is brighter and clearer than Power Grid’s fifty shades of grey. It’s a serious engine-builder at heart, though, with the dexterity element a small part of the game. You can play it mostly solo against other players, or you can play more competitively with a “take-that” strategy that swipes fuel cards your opponents might need. I think it’s a small gem of a game that deserves a wider audience than it’s gotten so far.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: , ,
→ September 13, 2022
→ By

Paris: La Cite de Lumiere & Eiffel.

Paris: La Cité de Lumière is a short but involved two-player game from 2019, bringing polyominos, tile-laying, and a unique drafting mechanism into a tight 30-minute playing time. It received a major expansion late last year in Paris: Eiffel, which debuted at Gen Con 2021 but hit the mass market this year, bringing further scoring cards to allow players to change strategies – but it doesn’t address my core issue with the game, the way the drafting forces you to potentially stop selecting building tiles.

Each player begins the game with eight square cobblestone tiles, each of which is divided into four squares that can be blue, orange, or purple, or just show a streetlight. One player is blue and the other is orange, while purple squares can belong to either player; you can only place a building on squares of your color or grey. In phase one, you may either place one of your cobblestone tiles on the game board, which is actually set inside the bottom of the box, or take one of the polyomino-shaped building tiles from the supply – but once you’ve placed all 8 of your tiles, you can’t take another building.

Paris: La Cité de Lumière base game.

In phase two, players alternate placing the building tiles they’ve taken on to the board. There are also eight Action cards placed around the board/box in each game, out of a set of 12 possible cards in the base game, which you can use to gain additional points or sometimes violate some of the rules of the game; each player has four action tokens that they will use to claim those cards during this phase, and once used a card can’t be reused. At game-end, you score for each of your buildings that is adjacent to a streetlight, earning the product of the number of lights and the number of squares covered by that building; and for your largest contiguous group of buildings, one point per square. You also gain a point for each postcard you used that shows a stamp, and lose 3 points for each building you took but failed to place (surprisingly easy to do).

The postcards are a huge part of the game because they’re so powerful. One allows you to place a fountain tile on cobblestones of your color or the neutral color, and then you get 3 points for each of your buildings that touches it. Another gives you a giant streetlight that lights up buildings two squares away rather than just adjacent spaces. Another gives you a purple cobblestone to place on a square of your opponent’s color, after which you immediately place a building on it. The game comes with a recommended set of eight cards for your first game or two, leaving some of the cards with complicated scoring for experienced players, although I don’t think there’s that much of a gap.

Paris: Eiffel adds eight more action cards, mostly based on actual landmark buildings in the city, and add new ways to score along with 3-D cardboard buildings you might place on the board. You still use just eight cards in the game, but can now mix and match from 20 choices rather than 12. The Eiffel Tower card lets you place the tower on a 4×4 area that contains at least one streetlight, after which those lights double their point value for scoring, while you also get two points for squares of your player color under the tower. The Obelisk (found in the Place de la Concorde) gives each player two points for every building they place that falls in the same row or column as the obelisk sits. Notre Dame and the Catacombs let you piggyback on one of your opponents’ buildings for more points or to count it in your largest building group. Quartres Pauvières lets you score for the number of board edges your buildings touch – 1, 2, 4, or 8 points.

The soring is definitely point salad-y, although the cards mean that the players get to pick their own scoring methods to some extent, and I think that’s probably the game’s greatest strength. It’s a novel approach to the asymmetrical two-player game. The weird drafting mechanism at the start just sinks the game for me, unfortunately. People do really love this game, though – it’s highly rated on BGG, which skews towards more complex games, but also has sold well enough to merit an expansion. It just isn’t my cup of thé.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: , ,
→ September 11, 2022
→ By

Stick to baseball, 9/11/22.

I pushed this post back a day so I could file another post for the Athletic, so you had two from me in the last 48 hours – a scouting post on some top Guardians and Nationals prospects, and a second edition of my looks at September prospect callups. I also held a Klawchat on Thursday.

Over at Paste, I reviewed Next Station: London, a great new flip-and-write game with a route-planning mechanic that makes it a sort of a puzzle – the choices you make early in the game constrain your choices later. This is definitely the year of the roll/flip-and-write.

My guest on this week’s episode of the Keith Law Show was Wingspan game designer Elizabeth Hargrave, talking about her next big game, The Fox Experiment, now on Kickstarter (and already 500% funded in five days). You can listen and subscribe via iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher, amazon, or wherever you get your podcasts.

And now, the links…

Longreads first: The New Yorker looks at how Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost and the Ottawa County police department have worked together to turn rape victims into defendants, putting one of their own on trial for accusing a cop – who has been accused by at least two other women of sexual assault – of coercing her into sex.

A column denying the extent of racism in Canadian society led to a successful effort to unionize the country’s conservative paper the National Post, securing gains for BIPOC employees in the process.

A Fox producer warned execs to stop Jeanine Pirro from airing her election-denial views, according to documents revealed in the Dominion Systems lawsuit against the right-wing juggernaut.

Billionaire Barre Seid has used his money to fund climate-change denialism and fight Medicaid expansion (that is, health care for our poorest citizens), while also funding a law school to churn out archconservative future judges, according to records unearthed by ProPublica.

One Alabama prison has been holding pregnant women there for weeks or months, in what appears to be a violation of basic Constitutional rights, to protect the fetuses from drug use.

David DeWitt of the Ohio Capitol Journal writes of the intolerable cruelty of Ohio’s total ban on abortions, including the suffering already of pregnant women needing essential medical care.

Nature’s editors write of the need for greater protections for scientists and researchers from threats and abuse, pointing at lawmakers and the executives running social media sites.

Rep. Kevin McCarthy, the House Minority Leader, introduced a new “Commitment to America” that is short on ideas and long on Trumpian insanity, according to Alex Shephard of the New Republic, pointing to the lack of details for how it will achieve vague goals, emphasis on truly counterproductive policies (like increasing fossil fuel production), and kowtowing to election deniers.

Oxford scientists may have developed an effective malaria vaccine. Malaria has long resisted traditional approaches to vaccine development because it’s caused by a parasite, rather than a bacterium or virus, and the parasite changes form once inside the host’s body.

Count me among those Duolingo users who hate the app’s total redesign, as it has removed most of the flexibility the old structure gave users to set their own pace; I used the app to try to keep my Spanish skills fresh, but wouldn’t do those lessons at the same speed or rate as those of Welsh, which I was learning from scratch. The founder’s comments don’t give me much hope, as they betrayed a real disdain for their customers.

I knew Florida state Rep. Randy Fine in college, and am not surprised to see the person he’s become as an adult or politician – he was one of the most vocal Florida officials to rail against “woke” Disney, but is also happy to spend thousands of dollars on the company’s cruises and products.

An 18-year-old student was elected to the Boise School Board, in no small part because his opponent refused to denounce an endorsement from a far-right extremist group that arrives armed with AR-15s to public events, supports book banning, and refers to undocumented immigrants as “illegals.”

As many GOP candidates across the country are trying to scrub anti-abortion or other hard-right rhetoric from their campaign sites, Pennsylvania gubernatorial candidate Doug Mastriano is leaning harder in that direction, becoming “Trumpier than Trump” in the words of Axios’ Jonathan Swan.

Lots of board game Kickstarters etc. this week, starting with the solo-only game Legacy of Yu from Shem Phillips, designer of Raiders of the North Sea and the North Sea and West Kingdom series of games.

Disney is introducing a new Magic: the Gathering-style collectible card game called Lorcana, and Polygon has images of some of the superb art.

Keith Matejka, designer of the Roll Player games, has a new title on Kickstarter called Dawn of Ulos, a tile-laying game for 1-5 players set in the Roll Player universe.

25th Century Games has a Gamefound campaign up for expansions to its Prehistories and Space Explorers games.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
→ September 8, 2022
→ By

Klawchat 9/8/22.

Keith Law: Come let the truth be shared. Klawchat.

Jackie: Paul Goldschmidt, the best player in Delaware’s history.  Future HOFer?
Keith Law: Yes. He could limp through the next few years and still make it. He’s going to clear 65 WAR with no trouble and could end up near 80 – that’s a no-doubter for me.

Kingpin: Nats IF Luis Garcia has 5 BB & 63 K in just under 300 AB. He’s only 22 iirc, so there’s still time for improvement, but his approach gonna hold him back?
Keith Law: Yes. Never been a big believer in that bat – he can put the bat on the ball but without impact or patience. Aggressive promotions when he was just a teenager may not have helped him in the end.

S. Murphy: Hey, Keith. Love the chats. Assuming all three of Peraza, Volpe, and Sweeney make it in the next two years to the majors.  What’s the most logical outcome for all three regarding playing time with the Yankees? I’m guessing Peraza at short, Volpe 2nd, Sweeney third, with DJ at first?
Keith Law: Sweeney isn’t near those other guys – he didn’t produce anywhere near the way a D1 product should in high A. Volpe is a shortstop and the guy you build around.

David (Denver): Given the Rockies’ bizarre management, I guess it makes as much sense as anything else they do or don’t do, but why isn’t a team like this more active on the waiver wire?  They should be claiming anyone with a pulse to maybe get lucky and find some free talent.  They just seem so content with the same underperforming roster year after year, while insisting that it just hasn’t quite reached expectations.  So why the process breakdown?
Keith Law: I agree, but they have a different philosophy than I would have if I ran that org. I’d probably run it like a science lab and just be experimenting constantly while trying to rebuild. They seem almost conservative for their situation.

John: Is there anything more inherently un-American than caring about the Queen of England?
Keith Law: Eh. Is it un-American to care about the Pope? A major world figure, the longest-reigning monarch in human history – yeah, I know about Louis XIV, he was five years old when he became king, he wasn’t actually in charge of anything beyond his own bowel movements – dies, that’s pretty big news.

DD: Are you a proponent of “steel-manning” when debating controversial topics?  Meaning, do you actively attempt to fairly restate the counterparty’s viewpoint and supporting logic/rationale, even if you strongly or vehemently disagree?
Keith Law: I have never heard of this, but it’s quite interesting.

Braves Questions: Was the Brian Bridges firing a result of the Carter Stewart signing issue?  I always liked his draft classes and am a little surprised Atlanta has apparently moved away from scouting to using more models for amateur evals under Brown.
Keith Law: I highly, highly doubt that. The team walked away from Stewart over his post-draft medical. You can’t blame that on the scouting director. And I agree, Bridges’s drafts look very successful in hindsight.

Sedona: Do you think Kerry Carpenter becomes an above avg MLB OF?
Keith Law: I do not.

JJ: Thoughts on Chaim Bloom?  The fanbase/media in Boston is just about ready to kick him to the curb.  Is he qualified to be the GM for the Red Sox?  It seems to me that a management position in Tampa Bay is a completely different animal than that job title with a team with twice the payroll, like the Red Sox or Yankees.
Keith Law: LOL. Yes, he’s qualified. I really don’t give a rat’s ass what the fanbase thinks and neither should anyone in that organization. I have vague memories of fans and media arguing that the Sox were wrong to move John Valentin to third base for an unproven rookie back in 1997.

The Ghost of Bobby Thigpen: Odds that Oscar Colas is the Sox starting RF next season on Opening Day?
Keith Law: They could always go outside the org, but he’s probably on their roster for a good chunk of next year in some role.

Sedona: There are some older MILB players that are showing 4 or more tools and excelling upper levels in the minors.  Some of them have a solid track record:  Vaun Brown, Matt Gorski, Addison Barger, Matt Mervis, and many more.  Do you see any of these guys will become MLB Stars?  If not, any off the radar older prospects you think that will become stars?
Keith Law: Well, Brown did most of that in A-ball at 24. I’ve seen Gorski (extra OF at best) and Barger (chance for a regular, more likely platoon IF). Mervis is 1B only so I’m not sure what the 4 tools would be.

Henry: I totally agree with your assessment that MLB owners will contract minor league teams if unionization goes through. What can the player’s association do to realistically stop that unintended consequence?
Keith Law: That’s a better question for a labor lawyer.

Nick: Jasson Dominguez has played really well since his promotion to high-a. Is he a possible riser on your next top 100?
Keith Law: He was already on my last top 100, and he’ll be on it again.

Casey: Alec Burleson was called up yesterday…do you think he’ll hit enough to be at least an average regular even with the defensive liabilities?
Keith Law: I’m a bit skeptical on the bat. Had him as more of a mistake hitter/power over hit type. He to be more than that to be a regular with the defensive issues you mentioned.

Kingpin: Do you see Jordan Walker creating more loft in his swing without hurting his contact too much?
Keith Law: Does he need to?

romorr: There are a lot of paths available for DL Hall next year, relief, AAA to continue starting, battling it out in ST, which would you like to see with him?
Keith Law: Start him in triple A unless there’s some real evidence between now and OD that he’s going to throw more strikes. I’m fine with him continuing to develop in the majors, but not if he’s going to walk 4 guys every start.

Jason: What’s up with Kahlil Watson, and can he turn things around and get back to where he was in your offseason ranking (obviously he won’t be there next January/February)?
Keith Law: Only 19, still showing tools, nowhere near as advanced a hitter as scouts thought coming out of HS. He’s been better with contact lately and driving the ball more but without enough results on contact.

Brittney: Safe to say the Cardinals were the winners of the 2020 draft? Any chance we see Hence on your Top 100 this winter?
Keith Law: Yes, and yes.

John: Should Andrew painter start next year with the Phillies?
Keith Law: Absolutely not.

Jason: What’s your honest take on the brewers? Seems like their starting pitching regressed. Is their offense that bad?
Keith Law: The offense was always going to be an issue. Their rotation hasn’t been at full strength most of the year, though.

AW: Have you seen enough from Volpe that he could provide a jolt down the stretch this season or does he still need some refinement in AAA?
Keith Law: I would call him up. I think he’ll rise to the occasion.

Robbie: If Harris and Strider were eligible to be on your prospect list today, would they both be top 5?
Keith Law: They’ve both got a year in the majors. That’s just not an apples to apples comparison.

Jobu: Which app would you recommend for learning a language?  I think you were using one to learning Welsh or Italian.
Keith Law: I used Duolingo and completed the Welsh course in it, but they recently changed the app to a very narrow, prescribed approach that stops you from learning at your own pace. I’m hoping they revert, given the negative feedback online, but the CEO/founder made some deeply paternalistic comments that make me think he’s dug in his heels.

Jimmy P: I’ve been waiting for the other shoe to drop on Elly ever since he joined High-A. A guy with his plate approach can’t sustain *this* in the majors, can he?
Keith Law: Maybe he can improve his approach? Really young and really talented.

Jeremy: Any thoughts on Tyler Soderstrom? He’s having a heck of a season with the bat but didn’t make your updated top prospects list – I know you’ve had an issue with his lack of a true position, is that what is keeping him off the list? Any other concerns?
Keith Law: That’s his #1 issue, yes.

Blaze Blaskovich: Ryne Nelson looked pretty nice – is that a fluke or does he have some mid rotation potential long term?
Keith Law: I’m in. Maybe an above-average starter.

Lark11: Have you heard any updates on Daniel Espino? Seems incredible that he’s going to miss the vast majority of the season with knee tendonitis and shoulder soreness. Any word on the severity of either? On when he’ll get back to throwing pitches in anger? Thanks!
Keith Law: I don’t think we see him till 2023.

romorr: Joey Ortiz has turned it around in a big way since July. And even his first week in AAA has impressed. Would you say his defense is better than Mateo this year? Shot to start out of ST?
Keith Law: Maybe not a better defender than Mateo but a much better overall player, and should be their OD shortstop next year.

jordan: in retrospect, should the white sox not have constructed their roster entirely with DHs and mediocre relief arms?
Keith Law: Perhaps not the ideal plan.

Guest: Keith is it true that rookie of the year has draft rewards and that’s why Dbacks and Orieloes may sit Carroll Gunner down the stretch some?
Keith Law: True, yes. Will they sit those guys? I don’t think either can lose eligibility even if they play every day.

Bill: Who would be a good fit for the Tigers’ GM position?
Keith Law: I’ve seen a bunch of good names and some extremely unimaginative ones. Josh Byrnes has been GM twice and succeeded in neither place. For him to get a third shot while qualified candidates, especially POC candidates, like Dana Brown, Jason McLeod, Billy Owens, Carlos Rodriguez, and others get passed over would be a giant fucking embarrassment for the Tigers and MLB.

Billiam: Endy Rodriguez any good?
Keith Law: Really good.

Josh: Strider or Harris for NL ROY?
Keith Law: I have an NL ROY ballot so I can’t answer.

romorr: Is Aberdeens park that bad for HR? Norby, and Cowser both put on a power display in Bowie. Norby especially has shown a little more than previously thought.
Keith Law: Other way around – Bowie is a very good HR park.

Lark11: Any thoughts on Reds shortstop Jose Barrero? It seemed like he things figured out at triple-A in 2021, then he fractures his hamate bone and now all he does is strikeout. Injury-related? Or, something less fixable? Thanks!
Keith Law: Hamate injuries can sap your wrist strength for a year. I’d wait and see.

Aaron C.: Tyler Soderstrom’s 2022 OBP is .319 between high A and AA. Why can’t us A’s fans have nice things?
Keith Law: If he were a catcher, it wouldn’t matter that much. But now, I don’t know what you have in him.

Adam: The Padres are currently still limping their way into the playoffs despite having Bob Melvin and a $200 mil roster. Can this be summed up with “baseball is hard” or is there an underlying cause to the struggles of AJ Preller’s rosters these last few years?
Keith Law: I mean, they have arguably the best player in the NL on their roster and he’s going to have 0 PA for them this year.

CVD: James Wood is a top ____ prospect going in to next season?
Keith Law: He was on my midseason top 50.

Lark11: Broad question, but what do you think of MLB’s recent trend of bringing all baseball-business in under the banner of MLB? I’m thinking of the minor leagues and of Topps. Is it good to acquire such business or better to have independent businesses growing your game for you? Also, is it a shady tactic to basically withhold licensing from Topps (who depends heavily on MLB cards) and then snatch it up for yourself? Or, is that standard business practice? Thanks!
Keith Law: Vertical integration is a mixed bag. In this case, MLB owning the minors might be better for player development, but worse for minor league fans, and maybe it’s just worse period if MLB owners persist in thinking of the minors as a cost center rather than an investment.
Keith Law: I have no idea about cards/licensing.

Pat: Thoughts on democrats’ strategy of helping extremist GOP candidates win their primaries?
Keith Law: It makes me nervous.

Alan: Last year you named Kyle Manzardo the sleeper of the Rays’ draft, which looks like a pretty good call. What do you expect from him — is a starting 1B/DH for a contender?
Keith Law: Starting 1B/DH for someone.

Paul: Hey Keith, I gotta ask you about Spencer Strider. He’s a very fun player to watch and interesting guy to root for. What do you make of his future? Does he need a 3rd pitch? Or is he just funky enough to where this current version of him can succeed for a while?
Keith Law: He gets LHB out right now, despite the lack of a third pitch. Every once in a very blue moon, you get a guy like this. I believe Bartolo Colon was this kind of pitcher when young – he could go through a lineup throwing mostly 4- and 2-seamers. But it’s rare, and one-year platoon splits are volatile enough that I’d like to see Strider do it over another season before buying into the argument that he can be an ace as a 2-pitch guy.

John: How does it effect your process when you see that two of the guys you were way low on (Goldy and Riley) are two of the better hitters in MLB?
Keith Law: Riley revamped his whole approach. Goldschmidt I just missed on, lacking enough looks and frankly overweighting input from scouts who, in hindsight, were disinclined to rate a player like him very highly. Two totally different cases – everything I said on Riley was accurate until he went out and addressed the clear holes in his approach, which is remarkable.

Jake: Does Trump get indicted before midterms, after, or not at all?
Keith Law: My guess, knowing basically nothing, is not at all.

Mike: Thoughts on the Guardians shortstop situation in the coming years? Rosario has been solid the past two years so is it worth keeping him or do you guy with Rocchio?
Keith Law: I think Rocchio’s a star. If Rosario doesn’t take a step forward with the bat next year, you just move him aside. He’s had a solid season but Rocchio will be better.

Michael: So the Cubs had a player debut the other day who did great. Looked him up and he’s a right wing nut. Is that just part of being a fan of a baseball team? On the one hand he’s a 20 something who’s probably not been exposed to alternative viewpoints. On the other hand yuck
Keith Law: For me, it would depend on his views. If he’s openly homophobic or transphobic or racist, I couldn’t root for him under any circumstances.

Jason: Re: John and the Queen of England, obviously the break in 1776 was a pretty big deal (and 1812, and supporting the Confederacy), but taking a broader view, we have a lot of shared history. We grew out of the British Empire, maintained their common-law legal system, have identified the “Special Relationship,” etc.
Keith Law: They have long been our greatest ally, and we have mostly been theirs.

Nick: Do you think Oswaldo Cabrera can hit enough at the mlb level to be a regular or is he more of a really good defensive utility player?
Keith Law: Utility guy.

Tim: Do you think Justin Steele could have a Jon Lester like career or is that asking too much?
Keith Law: I don’t see it. More like a fifth starter, of which the Cubs have a lot.

James: Will you be out at Arizona Fall League ? Hopefully rosters get announced any day
Keith Law: Yes, haven’t missed it since 2005.

Chris: Will Ceddanne Rafaela’s K rate keep him from becoming an MLB regular?
Keith Law: His K rate is fine. 20% or so.

Jon: How did teaching at Lincoln go? Are you going to do that again?
Keith Law: One of the hardest things I’ve ever done in my life. They invited me back but it was so much work and I needed to dedicate time to some other things, so I said no.

canada: Joey Meneses– real deal everyday player for the next few years, or just a flukey feelgood story that the Nats fans sorely need?
Keith Law: Flukey feel-good story.

Aaron: Last year you put Austin Riley’s WAR O/U at 5.5 and he currently sits at 5.4 on Fangraphs…

Has your projection of Spencer Strider at all changed based on what you’ve seen? I know it’s still a small sample but…..mighty impressive stuff so far.
Keith Law: Yes, for sure. The fastball is elite.

Heather: Huge difference between the Queen of England and the Bishop of Rome, as far as eighty million Americans are concerned.
Keith Law: We are not a Catholic nation. We were founded as a secular one.

PJ: Any thoughts on Wesneski’s debut for the Cubs?  I know it was against the Reds, but I’ve never seen a crowd as electric as that for two bottom-rung teams as they were watching Wesneski dominate that lineup
Keith Law: I think he’s sneaky good. Maybe just a reliever in the end but I’d start him first.

Guest: Thoughts on David Calabrese? You had him ranked fairly high in advance of the 2020 draft but then covid seemingly has impacted his development not unlike a lot of prospects from that draft.  He seems to be improving as of late.
Keith Law: He also got with a private hitting coach in the last year or so who screwed him up, but reverted back to his old swing in mid-July and you can see the results now. Probably shaking off a lot of rust too, since he’s Canadian and was stuck home during the pandemic.

Jeffrey: Why is Rougned Odor occupying a starting spot?  Anything besides “veteran presents”?
Keith Law: I have absolutely no idea.

David: Keith, re: Bloom. I think the biggest issue the fanbase has is that Bloom is the face of an organization that seems to be low-balling Devers, and after trading away Betts, losing Devers would cause a huge disconnect with fans. Think that’s a realistic possibility?
Keith Law: Yeah, but that’s not Bloom’s call, is it? That sounds entirely like ownership.

James: Who have you heard looks the best of all the new drafted guys so far in milb ? Small-ish sample
Keith Law: Very small sample and a lot of 21-year-olds mashing in low A, which they should do out of D1 schools.

Kevin: I think stealing classified nuclear documents and probably selling them off to Russia and saudi Arabia is more unamerican than caring about the queen.
Keith Law: As is defending the guy who did it.

Codey: do you think a team like az will trade some of these young outfielders? Carrol, Thomas, Varsho, McCarthy, Garrett seems like a lot
Keith Law: Carroll is a star and the guy you build around. Garrett is a great story but he’s the most expendable of the group. Thomas might be the best guy to trade because he could play CF for someone, just not for Arizona.

Tom: Any concern over Kiebert Ruiz’s meh offensive season?
Keith Law: No, and also I see a huge contact rate that I believe will turn into much more production next year.

Harris: How do you feel
Keith Law: to treat you like I do?

Codey: Has Brandon Pfafft of Dbacks farm raised his stock in your eyes?
Keith Law: No, he was already on my top 100 last winter.

Harris: How do you feel about the Harris extension?  I think it broke while you were on vacation.
Keith Law: Likely to pay off for the team, great for the player, more risk for the team than I think the general reaction would indicate.

Guest: Any notable 2022 draft debuts yet? Spencer Jones is performing really well in Tampa but he should be dominating in Low-A right?
Keith Law: Exactly. Rushing too. Props to Baltimore for pushing Dylan Beavers to high A, even just for two weeks.

Tim: Besides an injury is there anyway Andrew Painter’s not a top half of the rotation guy?
Keith Law: Sure, but I would not take that bet. I think he’s at least an above-average starter.

Aaron C.: The Oakland A’s have the worst OBP in MLB and have sacrifice bunted the third most times. Is intentionally giving up outs (on top of all the outs you’re ALREADY making) the new market inefficiency?
Keith Law: Imagine if I’d told you in 2004 that the 2022 A’s would be third in the AL in sac bunts. You would have asked me if Billy Beane was dead.

Jesse: Should Mets have known sproat wouldn’t sign? What exactly is going on there with him?
Keith Law: Why would they have known? My understanding is that the number he asked for after the draft differed from what he asked for before the draft. I have heard that he did something similar with Texas in 2019. At some point, you have to just accept that this is how the industry values you.

Robbie: This time next year – who will be the #1 prospect in baseball
Keith Law: Right now I’d guess Chourio.

Leites: Hi Keith!  Who would you rather have at this point – Bo Naylor or Ivan Herrera?  Which do you think has a better shot at becoming an average or above average MLB hitter?
Keith Law: I was a big Naylor guy in the draft, just sort of threw my hands up with his miserable 2021. Couldn’t be happier to see him develop into the player I thought he’d be. Athletic, quick-twitch, with feel to hit and more power at his age than I anticipated.

Jake: Any thoughts on Nick Yorke? Can you chalk this year up to injuries or are there deeper issues from what you’ve seen/heard?
Keith Law: Not giving up on him but he does highlight the risk of players whose value is entirely in their hit tool. He’s looked more like a regular this year than an above-average or better one.

Nick: Is Spencer Jones a top 100 candidate? He’s had a pretty hot start to his career and apparently the exit velo number are off the charts.
Keith Law: My top 100 is most definitely not a ranking of exit velos.

Tre: If you were running the Orioles, who would you target this offseason?
Keith Law: Every starting pitcher with a pulse.

Dave: Have you read anything else by Emily St. John Mandel besides Station Eleven?  I have The Glass Hotel and Sea of Tranquility on my shelf; was curious if you’d cracked either open.
Keith Law: Glass Hotel is beautifully written but Mandel didn’t stick the landing.

ZIrinsky: Would you sign Judge to a long-term (8+ years) contract or reallocate that money under the assumption that he’s probably already played his best baseball?
Keith Law: Unfortunately, the latter. His age, body, injury history point to an 8-year deal ending very poorly. Love the player, would try to go for a market-topping 4-5 year deal.

Codey: Do you believe the DBacks trade Gallen this off season? Also the cardinals trading him in the Ozuna trade feels like one of most lopsided in years yeah?
Keith Law: Yikes, I wouldn’t counsel that – he’s your ace next year, Kelly and Nelson behind him, hopefully Pfaadt gets there, try to get to 85 wins.

Leites: Who do think is a better bet at this point to develop a workable hit tool – Josh Lowe or Jarred Kelenic?
Keith Law: Not giving up on either player, although I wonder if Kelenic is just way too hard on himself, and might be better off in another place where he’s not dealing with the same expectations. I rarely say that about players but he looks like a different guy in the majors.

Tommy: What is Garrett Whitlock, long term?  A starter?  A closer?  A multi-inning reliever?  I suppose it’s OK that I’m not sure what he is, but I get the feeling the Red Sox aren’t sure, either.
Keith Law: Multi-inning reliever works for me. Don’t think he’s a starter.

Adam: If Busch stadium is not selling a confection called the Noot Bar, I will be severely disappointed.
Keith Law: It’s just Noot very good!

Zach: I recall you weren’t too high on Nick Lodolo when he came up, but he’s had an impressive rookie season despite another dumpster fire of a year from the Reds. Any change in his outlook from your perspective? Thanks.
Keith Law: He hasn’t, though – he’s been on the IL yet again, and has a huge platoon split, as predicted.

James: Have you heard anything about GCU shortstop Jacob Wilson for the 2023 draft ?
Keith Law: Saw him and wrote a little about him in March. Potential first-rounder, more like a clear day-one guy.

JL: I can’t recall if you’ve stated here or elsewhere before your stance on some of the new CBA items. But what is your stance on the shift being banned and pitch clocks?I vaguely remember  Would you consider a piece before next year on the various new rules?
Keith Law: Don’t like banning the shift. That’s just stupid. The pitch clocks in the minors have been a huge help for game times, though.

Sean: With Griffin McGarry at LHV as reliever do you forsee him being the first to see Philly out him Painter and Abel with Painter having the largest upside?
Keith Law: Yes. Even money they call McGarry up as a reliever this month.

addoeh: What would your entrance song from the bullpen be?  Think I’d go with Pink Floyd’s One of These Days.
Keith Law: Butthole Surfers’ “Who Was in My Room Last Night?” Tell me that guitar riff wouldn’t get the crowd going.

James: Keith what ever happened with Scott Kingery ?? He looked promising as a prospect and I know you liked him – just get a bag of money and stop caring ?
Keith Law: Jeez, that’s an uncharitable assumption. They messed with his swing. He’s never recovered from it.

Jason: Can Matt Brash be an effective starter?
Keith Law: I don’t believe so.

Tom: What do you think Pfaadt’s ceiling is? He’s been mowing ’em down in Reno
Keith Law: More like a solid-average starter, less ceiling than Nelson/Jameson but very predictable.

Chris: I always struggle looking at players with big AA/AAA stats who never show up on prospect lists. What are typically the flaws in those players that you notice? Example- Andres Chaparro. 23 with a 922 OPS at AA. Not on NYY top 30. Is he a non-prospect?
Keith Law: He’s not a prospect. I’ve seen him a bunch. Bad body guy and power over hit. OPS isn’t a great stat for evaluating players but especially not prospects.

addoeh: Nico Hoerner.  About what you expected at SS or a bit better?
Keith Law: Much better defensively than I expected. Will be curious to see if that holds up.

Lark11: If you were starting a baseball team and had the power to pick the position at which your best/star/leader player would play, what position would you pick? Starting pitcher? Catcher? Shortstop? Somewhere else?
Keith Law: Shortstop.

JC: What is going on with Kyren Paris and his recent ’76 Joe Morgan impersonation? Is he just on a SSS lucky streak or has he tapped into something?
Keith Law: Bit of both. Very young when drafted, like Calabrese. Needed to gain a lot of strength.

romorr: Kyle Bradish has shown flashes this year, but has he shown enough to start in the rotation next year? I’ll throw Kremer in there as well as a bit of a question mark.
Keith Law: Kremer can start, Bradish is a reliever for me with that delivery.

Mike: Do you think KeBryan Hayes can revamp his swing?  Seems to hit the ball hard when he makes contact, but mostly on the ground.
Keith Law: I think he could, and he’d be a 20-25 homer guy if he did.

JL: Pardon the ignorant question, but could you explain why a changeup is more affective to a batter of opposite handedness?
Keith Law: If you’re a RHP, your breaking pitches will break in to lefties, and thus right into their bat paths. If you leave those pitches up at all, even if they’d be good strikes against RHB, lefties can and should hit them. Without a change/split, opposing-side batters just have to decide “fastball or breaking ball,” and if they get that right, they have a great chance to make contact.
Keith Law: I’m a strong advocate of the splitter for any pitcher who can’t figure out a good CH, which can be an issue for guys who throw everything hard.

stixx23: There’s another Yankees single-season record in jeopardy this year. Cole is only 30K behind Guidry’s 248 in 1978. Do you find this list as strange as I did? Eight different pitchers (it was nine before last night) on the list as opposed to one dominating.
Keith Law: That Guidry year was something else, too. I wish I remembered it – I was five, probably saw a bunch of his starts but at that age would have had no real concept.

stixx23: Sorry, didn’t know return key would send message. Here’s the Yankees top 10 K in a season list:
1.Ron Guidry•1978 248
2.Gerrit Cole•2021 243
3.Jack Chesbro•1904 239
4.CC Sabathia•2011 230
Luis Severino•2017 230
6.David Cone•1997 222
7.Luis Severino•2018 220
8.Gerrit Cole•2022 218
Melido Perez•1992 218
10.Al Downing•1964 217
Keith Law: MELIDO PEREZ?

Ben: If Judge passes 61 dingers, do you consider him the “rightful” single season HR leader?
Keith Law: No, because I live in the real world.

Harrisburg Hal: when playing a new game, do you start with written instructions or online videos?
Keith Law: Depends on the game & its complexity level. Online videos can be great.

Punk in Drublic: Little off topic but do you have a link to a page where you have recommendations for different kitchen items (cutlery, sous vide, cast iron pan, etc). Just bought a home and need to outfit my 1st decent kitchen.
Keith Law: Yep, last time I updated it was 2019 but it all still holds: https://klaw.me/2DB4rf5

Jason S: A lot of teams are going to regret drafting Cam Collier, agree?
Keith Law: Not drafting him – yes, I think they are going to regret it.

Nick: So no? I mean exit velo is  predictive of success at the major league level. Teams use it in the minors for a reason. Seems pompous to dismiss it.
Keith Law: In isolation, it doesn’t tell us a whole lot, no, and that is all you offered. I mean, ONeil Cruz hits the ball as hard as anyone, ever, and he’s struggling at the moment. As for “teams use it in the minors,” they track it, but they do not “use it” as the sole measure of a player.

Ken: Why is there still a Royal family in 2022?
Keith Law: Cause tourists are money.

JT: Corbin Carroll’s swing (shut off stance) and body type (midget/anorexic) look exactly like Mike Fontenot’s. How can be possibly be a #1 overall prospect
Keith Law: I debated not posting this, but I wanted to tell you how incredibly offensive your language is. Grow up.

Walt: Way early to think about the 2023 Draft I’m sure, but do you have any early thoughts on the chances Chase Dollander going 1-1?
Keith Law: I’ll take the field right now.
Keith Law: There is no clear 1-1 candidate for next year, not right now.

Lark11: Regarding Elly De La Cruz, how exactly do you go about developing a “plate approach” when the player has such absurd tools? Do you keep advancing him until he *has* to get a better approach to succeed? Do you instruct him to take until he gets to a certain count? Do you teach him how to look for certain pitchers in certain counts? How do you develop/improve a plate approach with a sublimely gifted athlete?
Keith Law: Yes – you push him. He’s going to outathlete his level for a while. Make him struggle and hope he’s up to the challenge, mentally and intellectually.

James: Did you see Bill Simmons had your book Smart Baseball on his shelf behind him in recent tik tok ?
Keith Law: I didn’t but that’s great to hear.

Bo: Will KC ever move on from Sal Perez, and give the Catching job to MJ Melendez
Keith Law: They need to, yes.

Nick: I didn’t say exit velo would be the only reason. I said is he in consideration for the top 100 considering he’s off to a hot start and the exit velo has been good. As a first round pick I thought it was a legitimate question. Most top prospects coming up now have elite exit velo numbers.
Keith Law: He shouldn’t have been a first round pick, and you’re affirming the consequent here: Most top prospects coming up have elite exit velo numbers, but that doesn’t mean that most players with elite exit velo numbers are top prospects.
Keith Law: Jones has big power. He’s 6’7″ with a below-average approach and the history of position players his size is not good at all.

James: Do you still play Catan ?
Keith Law: Almost never. Too long, requires 3 players minimum, lots of other games I prefer.

JR: Does an author’s public views ever sour your perception of their body of work, and make you refuse to read their future work, even if it’s enjoyable? I’m currently reading the new Cormoran Strike book because I’m a fan of the series, but feel a little guilty about it.
Keith Law: Yes, in some cases. I would have a hard time reading her new work, at least.

Guest: Carson Whisenhunt looks like an absolute steal for the Giants. Do you think we could see him in SF in 2023?
Keith Law: 2024 is much more likely. I agree that pick was great value.
Keith Law: That’s all for this week – thanks for joining me and for your patience while I was on vacation etc. during August. Scouting blog & several new columns coming soon! Stay safe and go get that booster.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: