So, I haven’t actually seen the movie The Martian, because I told myself I really wanted to read the book first, and 2015 was one of my in-between years when I didn’t see all the Oscar nominees. (I did see Spotlight, all five animated nominees, Ex Machina, and The Force Awakens, and nothing else from that year until we watched What Happened, Miss Simone? last year during the lockdown.) And then … I never read the book, until a few weeks ago, when I got the book on sale as an e-book, and I actually read the book. I suppose now I should see the movie, because the book, while flawed, is pretty good.
The book, which came out in 2011, is a perfect exemplar of hard science fiction: Author Andy Weir spends a significant portion of the text getting the science right, but it is mostly in service of the greater story. Mark Watney is one of the astronauts on a manned mission to Mars, and a series of accidents on the surface, spurred by a massive dust storm, has Watney left on the surface, presumed dead, while the ship takes off without him. Of course, he’s very alive, and has to find a way to survive until the next manned mission arrives – and get himself to that site – or, possibly, communicate with NASA to let them know he’s still alive. Eventually (mild spoiler), NASA figures it out, and they arrange a rescue mission that captivates the world.
There’s a lot of technical detail in The Martian, especially for a novel aimed at a popular audience, enough to give me some bad Red Mars memories, but Weir manages to keep those details from bogging down the text too much by putting all of those specifications in Watney’s voice. The narrative settles quickly into a rhythm where Watney conceives a plan, goes through the details (for the reader), and then executes it. Some plans work, some don’t, and in the latter case we do the whole thing over again. It only works, though, because Watney is a smart-ass, with plenty of the smart and, especially once he starts communicating with others, plenty of the ass, too.
What works a little less well, however, is the way that Weir throws one obstacle after another in Watney’s way, which might work in some contexts but here does become repetitive, in a “not again” sense – just when it appears that he’s on a path that might lead him to a rescue, even though you know even that will still be arduous and difficult, Weir pulls the threadbare rug out from under his main character. Later in the book, after Watney has reestablished a bare minimum of communication with NASA, which helps the text tremendously – there is no actual dialogue involving the book’s protagonist until that point, since he is, obviously, alone on a whole planet – Weir cuts it off. It’s not that the rescue thus becomes more difficult and unlikely; it’s that the text benefited so much from having Watney involved in even limited dialogue with another human.
In the end, though, it works, because Weir has created a great lead character in Watney, and that carries the story – not the technical details, as accurate as they may be. (There’s a bit of a Terraforming Mars vibe, here, although that game was directly inspired by Kim Stanley Robinson’s Mars trilogy.) Watney is a wiseass, and the wit helps balance out the dry (pun intended) details for the long stretches where it’s just him, alone, trying to figure out how to survive long enough to get to the next step, and maybe keep himself alive until the next planned manned mission arrives on Mars. I don’t think The Martian is for everyone, but if you can hang with the technical stuff, there’s a smart, occasionally fun Robinson Crusoe-in-space story here that I enjoyed quite a bit.
Next up: I’m reading an advance copy of Elizabeth Hinton’s America on Fire: The Untold History of Police Violence and Black Rebellion Since the 1960s, which comes out on May 18th.
You should definitely watch the movie, as it improves on the issue you had. Also, do you consider casting decisions a spoiler for the movie? There’s one I’d love to talk about and how it plays into one of the jokes in the book, but I don’t want to ruin anything.
I don’t really know, but I’ll watch the movie soon and write something when I do, so maybe you could hold off a few weeks?
Of course.
Great timing on the review. I’m not sure if you did this on purpose or not but Weir’s third book, Project Hail Mary, came out today. It’s another stranded-astronaut-in-space adventure and, as someone who loved The Martian, I’m very excited.
oh yeah, I … uh … totally did that on purpose (I did not).
I loved the book. It was such a breezy read despite all the technical aspects. I thought the only part of the book that was a slog for me was the long ride at the end.
I’d definitely recommend the movie. It was a lot of fun. I didn’t like all the choices the filmmakers made. Some improved the overall story, others seemed like choices that didn’t need to be made. I’ll be curious to hear your thoughts once you’ve seen it!
Though this would be about Jasson Dominguez, so I’m out
Good stuff. I read the book & the movie & it’s one of the rare instances where I think I liked the movie more because:
– As mentioned the technical details in the book can slow down the narrative some.
– Really good cast. Matt Damon, obviously (& a great choice to play Watney), but, Jessica Chastain, Kate Mara, Jeff Daniels, Sean Bean, Chiwetel Ejiofor, Sebastian Stan, Michael Pena. Not all of them are well developed characters (How could they be? esp when it’s really Watney’s story), but, all familiar faces that chew some scenes & make it an easy watch.
– They have a cheesy 70’s soundtrack going throughout that adds some enjoyment (& a good running gag between Damon & Chastain).
I’m a big fan of the book (which I read well before the movie came out), and then I enjoyed the movie as well. In the “rewatchable/re-readable” sense I return to both the book and the movie often as entertaining even on revisit.
I agree with your critiques though, and you’ll be happy with the parts of the story that the movie leaves out. i also did not have the same criticisms that others have had with the science aspect of his plight (picking nits about how many vitamins did they really bring up, or the creature comforts of the Hab as depicted in the movie).
I hope you enjoy the movie!