Before I get to Philly, a few of you have asked about the restaurant where my cousin is the pastry chef. It’s called City Limits Diner, and there are two locations, one on the edge of White Plains near Yonkers, the other in Stamford, Connecticut. My cousin is the pastry chef and her husband is the executive chef. I wouldn’t bring it up if I didn’t genuinely like the food. If you do go, make sure you have dessert, and tell your server that Tracy’s cousin Keith sent you (not that it will get you anything, but it’ll score me some points).
I ate all of my non-ballpark meals in Philly at Reading Terminal Market, an eating paradise on Filbert between 11th and 12th streets, right across from the Market East train station. I could have stayed a week and still had places there I wanted to try.
For breakfast, I hit the Dutch Eating Place – Dutch as in Pennsylvania Dutch, a community responsible for at least ten of the stands around the market. They’re best known for their blueberry pancakes, which were solid average or a bit above, and for their cured meats, which were a mixed bag – the pork sausage was meaty and peppery and the portion was beyond generous, but the turkey bacon was gamey and greasy. I also tried their “apple” french toast, which as far as I can tell, was just some whole or multi-grain sandwich bread, dipped in egg batter, fried, and topped with too much cheap cinnamon, with no evidence whatsoever of apples. The pancakes were worth a trip, though. Cash only, cost $10 including tea and tip both days.
DiNic’s serves hot Italian sandwiches in just a few varieties, but everyone recommended the roast pork, thinly sliced, served on fresh crusty Italian bread, with just a few possible toppings – sharp provolone, roasted peppers (sweet or hot), broccoli rabe, or spinach. I went with the rabe and sweet peppers. The sandwich was about a foot long, so I barely got halfway through it, and the inside of the bread was soaked with the juice of the pork (that’s a good thing). For about $8 it’s a bargain and was the best thing I ate on the trip.
Delilah’s Soul Food had some of the best fried chicken I’ve ever eaten. Even though the chicken was more warm than hot when I got it, the crust was still crispy, not greasy, and was well seasoned with salt and pepper without having too much of either. For $8.50 or so you get chicken, cornbread (the sweet kind, unfortunately), and one side; I chose collard greens and got a big bowl that I got maybe halfway through and then poured the juice at the bottom over the cornbread. It’s one of the few places in RTM with table service.
The Famous Fourth Street Cookie Company had a long line around lunch time on my first trip there; the cookies are constantly coming out of the oven, so you can get something hot at that hour, although I found that at room temperature a few hours later, they were just average cookies. They’re a good four inches or so in diameter and cost about $2 apiece. The “double chocolate chip” is just a chocolate chip cookie with a lot of chips, and the chocolate chip with pecans didn’t skimp on the nuts.
I grabbed a pumpkin muffin from Le Bus Bakery for the flight home; it was a bit greasy, staining the paper bag, but it didn’t have the usual pumpkin muffin flavor of stale pumpkin pie spice mix, and it wasn’t overly sweet. There was a faint spicy note, almost like cardamom, but otherwise the pumpkin was allowed to take its place at the center of the muffin.
Leaving RTM, La Colombe is a small cafe best known for its coffee-roasting operation, as they apparently supply many of the best restaurants in town. I found their espresso to be far too watery with no body, but it did have a defined flavor, with strong notes of cocoa beans and a pleasant acidity. My guess is that the beans were from Africa, although I’m no expert on varietals since I always use blends to make espresso at home.
I learned about Capogiro Gelato a few years ago on the short-lived Food Network show, The Hungry Detective, a good concept dressed up with a few too many gimmicks but with plenty of emphasis on the actual food. They have at least one more location now, at 13th and Walnut, very close to my hotel and the RTM. The gelato is very expensive – a medium, roughly 3/4 cup of gelato, cost $6.15 with tax – but outstanding quality. I got three flavors, figuring that was almost an obligation to my readers: dark chocolate, coconut, and toasted almond. The almond was a waste, as the gelato itself had almost no flavor; it comes with toasted slivered almonds, but the flavor needs to be in the gelato, not on it. The coconut was ultra-smooth with a strong, clean coconut flavor. The dark chocolate stole the show, probably the darkest, richest chocolate ice cream I’ve ever had, with a thick consistency more like cocoa pudding ice cream than a typical chocolate gelato; a medium cup of that might be overkill, but I’m willing to risk it.
I didn’t eat at any concessions at CBP, but it’s worth mentioning that the press box food was, by press box food standards, impressive. The worst part of eating while traveling is how hard it is to eat fruits and vegetables while sticking to quick, inexpensive places, and the CBP press box had cups of fresh fruit, a basic salad mix that wasn’t brown or wilted or dried out, and a few vegetable side dishes each night. I know this isn’t of much use to the majority of you, but I wanted to give credit to the Phillies for doing a nice job.
Keith does not lie about City Limits; it is indeed excellent food.
Had Capogiro tonight! Black Cherry, Sea Salt, Madagascar Vanilla, and Chocolate/Malt. KLAW, you should have stopped at Vietnam, just two blocks from Reading Terminal!
No cheesesteaks?
No apple dumplings at Dutch???
wow, city limits. i used to go there in high school after practices and whatnot. isnt there another one in the westchester (the mall)? i dont remember the quality of the food much, but that was a while ago. small world.
jason, i’m not sure if it’s still there, but there was indeed one in the mall for a long time.
Dan, it seems that Keith isn’t crazy about them. When I was there, I thought they were exceptional, right from the street peddlers even. Of course, Philly was experiencing a cabbie strike and I didn’t have a car so I was limited as to where I could go, but still…
Is that Delilah’s famous for its Mac & Cheese. I saw several shows featured her, so I wonder…
The mall location closed in December ’08.
I have zero interest in a cheesesteak. Especially if they’re putting some fake processed cheese garbage on it.
Yes, that’s the Delilah’s known for its mac and cheese (another dish I just flat-out won’t eat).
Keith…visited Philly a couple of months ago and stumbled upon a little Wine/Beer & Cheese cafe called Tria. Very nice wine and beer selection and some great cheeses. A nice little sit-down for a snack.
As a displaced New Yorker now living near Philly, I can attest to the fact that while Philly is famous for the cheesesteaks, the italian roast pork sandwich is the real delight of Philly cuisine. Sharp Provolone and broccoli rabe is the popular choice; I think the sharp provolone is not to be missed, but I pass on the rabe myself. The other ubiquitous Philadelphia food is “Tomato Pie”, which as far as I can tell is just unfinished pizza, and I wouldn’t wish it on anyone. Still, they seem to love that stuff down here.
I find a general lack of flavour in most nut varieties of gelato, save pistachio. In Italy I was excited to try a coconut/macadamia combination but the macadamia was flavourless. I’ve heard Capogiro carries a Black Mission Fig variety. When I was in Spain I tried fig and it was the best gelato I had ever tasted.
Drew — To be fair, the tomato pie is actually more of a Central/South Jersey phenomenon than a Philly one per se (Trenton claims to be its “home” and it is ubiquitous in Central Jersey and parts of Bucks County, PA as well). For the definitive version of this (which is much, much better than you might imagine) DiLorenzo’s in Trenton has no peer (and turns out many other wonders from its coal-fired oven).
I couldn’t agree more vis-a-vis the roast pork with sharp provolone and broccoli rabe — sublime sandwich. DiNics makes a phenomenal one (as Keith found out) but John’s and Tony Luke’s turn out similarly inspired efforts.
Keith, been awhile since I poked around, good to be back. First, small world we live in, City Limits is right up the road from me. For a diner, food is pretty good there. ALWAYS PACKED. I will give a shout out to Tracy when my wife and I return there.
Secondly, as I’m sure you appreciate a good pizza, New Haven’s Frank Pepe’s is coming to Westchester in 2 weeks, opening up 15 mins down the road from City Limits on Central Ave. We are doing a feature on the opening on our blog Sunday Sauce, and if you are down in Westchester anytime soon would like to meet up there and talk chow.
Lastly, regarding gelato there was a wonderful spot in Florence, on the Via Corso which is adjacent to the famous Piazza Della Signora (home of the fake David Statue and where Savronola was executed). Name escapes me right now. Still haven’t tasted great gelato in NY/NJ though and I’m looking hard!