Stick to baseball, 6/26/20.

I had one new piece for The Athletic subscribers this week, talking to player development execs about what they plan to do this summer and fall with minor leaguers who may not get to play in any games this year. (I’m extremely pessimistic about instructional league or the Arizona Fall League, given those states’ incompetent responses to the ongoing pandemic.) I also held a Klawchat on Thursday, and a Periscope video chat on Wednesday.

At Paste, I reviewed Santa Monica, a really cute, mostly clever new game that just doesn’t quite work because there aren’t enough ways to use one of the most important mechanics in the game.

The Boston Globe recently named my second book, The Inside Game: Bad Calls, Strange Moves, and What Baseball Behavior Teaches Us About Ourselves, one of its recommended sports reads for the summer. The book has garnered similar plaudits from major publications as a Father’s Day gift or for summer reading, including from ForbesThe New York Times, and Raise. My thanks to all of you who’ve already bought it; if you’re looking to pick up a copy, you can get it at bookshop.org or perhaps at a local bookstore if they’re reopening near you.

I’m sending out my free email newsletter a bit more regularly lately, although I took this week off since I didn’t have much to say. You can sign up for free here.

And now, the links…

  • Elizabeth Kolbert, winner of the Pulitzer Prize for Non-Fiction for her book The Sixth Extinction, looks at how Iceland beat COVID-19, with virtually no cases and one of the world’s lowest fatality rates, for the New Yorker.
  • MEL‘s Isabelle Kohn looks at police officers who commit domestic violence – how it ties to violence against unarmed black citizens, and how often these officers get away with it, even to the point of killing their partners.
  • Henry Abbott of TrueHoop added his thoughts on the Bill Simmons situation, explaining how much ESPN catered to Simmons during the time they were both there. I saw some of this firsthand around Grantland, which always had resources that should have gone to the main site. I never had any negative interactions with Simmons myself.
  • Astronomers may have discovered a black neutron star, which would fill in the ‘mass gap’ between lighter neutron stars and heavier, denser black holes.
  • Three Wilmington, North Carolina, police officers were fired for stating that they’d like to kill all Black people and making other racist comments. The comments only came to light because one of their cameras was activated inadvertently; otherwise, they’d still be on the job, armed, planning to kill as many Black people as they could.
  • No link yet, but Ravensburger announced the five villains that will be available in the upcoming Marvel Villainous: Infinite Power game, a standalone expansion that will be available for preorders on July 6th: Thanos, Hela, Ultron, Killmonger, and Taskmaster.

Comments

  1. Small correction, it’s Henry Abbott of TrueHoop, not Henry Simmons. He also wrote this piece this week that details some of the same things you said.

    https://www.truehoop.com/p/do-i-get-to-speak-now-its-been-like

    How long until Parler goes the way of Gab and Conservapedia?

    • Thanks. I think that’s the same piece?

      The funniest part about Parler is that they’re not bothering to verify anyone’s identity. It’s just going to turn into a shitshow if it isn’t one already.

    • Looks like your link goes to a podcast he had on the subject, which was also good.

      The Bulwark had another piece this week on the kinds of shit that exists in Parler, from George Floyd trurthers, to Holocaust denial, to your typical anti-Semitism and racism, to a bunch of user names with the N word.

      https://thebulwark.com/the-gross-hellscape-that-awaits-ted-cruz-on-parler/

    • I thought it was me (my computer has been doing strange things today). Unfortunately, videos and podcasts don’t work well through my work remote portal, so if I want to hear it it’ll need to wait.

      I really enjoyed Simmons in his early days on ESPN, when he could realistically present himself as a “regular guy fan” (even if it was of everything Boston!). I thought he got a bit full of himself as he grew in popularity, and gave up on him shortly after he set up Grantland. These days, I don’t even bother.

  2. Brian in ahwatukee

    I remember reading Simmons in page 2 as the sports guy. He was innovative and funny. Then he started to do the same things over and over that he’d done before and it became uninteresting. He then got into using methods he’d had success with sports writing but he’d do it with pop culture. He was no longer the sports guy but edgy people magazine and he got even less interesting. I remember being interested in Grantland when he launched it but it was a bunch of inside jokes and articles on pop culture that weren’t particularly interesting. It was supposed to be like a modern Sports Illustrated but again, it failed badly at that.

    I had no idea he was still a personality because honestly he stopped being interesting 10 years ago.

    • Simmons has really fallen off. His best “skill” at this point is an eye for talent. Half his staff are Simmons-wannabes and they’re a dime a dozen. But alot of them are really talented and worth listening to/reading. The hard part is figuring out which are which.

    • I agree with pretty much everything you said, Brian. The thing that really killed off Simmons for me was his HBO show. What a complete mess that was.

    • Yeah, there’s only so many Teen Wolf/MTV Real World/Melrose Place references and podcasts with his college buddies JackO and House one can do before it gets stale. And his Manute Bol comment from his basketball book is pretty cringe worthy. I haven’t really paid much attention to him in close to a decade and given what he received from Spotify, he hasn’t missed me.

  3. I stopped caring about Simmons himself once he become a podcaster instead of a writer, but he was a great writer once, Grantland was my favorite site on the internet, and I’m struck by how petty some of the criticism from ESPNers has been.

    I get that he was coddled, but he was a talented content producer; I’m sure that’s not the first time that’s happened in the entertainment business. When someone feels the need to tell me about how Simmons wears “carefully purchased jeans” (Whoa! better check my privilege; I carefully purchase my clothing too), “deniable mousse” in his hair, and succeeded because of his talent for schmoozing higher ups…. uh, ok. I thought Grantland was a great site because he did a great job of finding unheralded writing talent, but what do I know.

    • He was an engaging writer in a style that is not as easy as it seems. And he has elevated many talented young writers whose work I follow to this day, which I’ll always appreciate about him. I also enjoyed his podcast for a good while, but it got less interesting as he pared down his guest list to the same few people — some of whom come across as sycophantic, others who sound tired of him, and also Ryen Russillo, a uninteresting grouch. Don’t know about the workplace issues, except to say that the erstwhile Girls In Hoodies seem to studiously avoid talking about him.

    • I also remain troubled by the site’s handling of the outing of a trans woman during the investigation of a goddamn golf putter. There were like 9000 (well documented) things that went wrong there. To his credit, he wrote a thoughtful apology and spoke of steps he’d take to avoid such failings going forward.

      And then on the subsequent podcast got all cranky and basically said he was done talking about it. Sorry that ruining a woman’s life (she committed suicide after the writer outed her to an investor) is so inconvenient to you.

      Oh… and as we’re seeing they continue to have major issues respecting folks other than straight white cis guys.

    • I’m trying my best to curb my bias, having followed Simmons for nearly 20 years, but the reactions to the NYT piece seem a bit much. I think he has owned his only-child-ness forever, and has consistently tried to re-read situations that he may have gotten wrong the first time around. He doesn’t always change his mind, and he is hyper-competitive in a way that doesn’t always make sense to me, but I always thought Grantland had done well to cultivate a diverse group of voices. I also felt like he was an internal champion for The Undefeated, and Jason Whitlock in particular. And I think in this case, too, it seems like Bill is acknowledging that they haven’t done as well as they’d like to in promoting minority voices and they’re trying to get better. I know I’m missing a lot, and there’s no reason I should be more supportive of management than the writers, but I don’t like the easy piling-on.

    • That said, I definitely can’t disagree with anything in the posts above (except that I actually really like his podcasting). I’d also add that his humor sources skewed so bro-y forever that I had come to gloss over them in his writing. But re-reading a piece from Emma Span about the Book of Basketball, I’m viewing that in a new light (and kind of really upset, reading it as if I’m coming to it totally new to his writing).

      http://www.bronxbanterblog.com/2010/12/17/the-book-of-basketball-and-staggering-casual-sexism/

      I think he’s tried to grow from that, but that stuff doesn’t get unwritten.

    • Good points. Some of the attacks are petty and seem rooted in jealousy. Even I’ve had to push past some. Like, a lot of his Boston-bro persona is kind of bull… he grew up a prep school kid in Fairfield, CT, closer to NYC than Boston… but most writers have a shtick that is only so authentic and hating on his specifically is needless.

      There is some incongruity in this area in particular… he has elevated some voices of color but there is also an incredible whiteness to much of what he creates. It’s… complicated. I wonder if finances are part. At Grantland, his funding was from ESPN/Disney and I doubt that model was so predicated on raw numbers and bottom line analysis (an assumption but I could be wrong). At The Ringer, I got a VC vibe from the model and they ultimately sold to Spotify. So Grantland felt a bit “purer” and maybe allowed him to focus more on quality while the Ringer had different incentives and may have led to the cringey “open mic” comment.

      If he is all/more about the finances, it doesn’t make him uniquely bad but does put him at odds with his own history and claims on the matter and I think that’s fanning some of this.

  4. Hi Keith,

    I don’t have Twitter and so I’m hoping you see and answer this question. Can you please give me your baseball opinion of Marlins GM Mike Hill. At my 30000 level I can’t see how he still has a job. The team hasn’t finished above .500 in the last 10 years and somehow has managed to trade away Christian Yelich, Luis Castillo and Chris Paddack for what seems like a bucket of balls under his watch. I refuse to chalk up all of the above to Loris, if Hill was so good at what he does I have to believe there would be rumors of other teams going after him like an Epstein or Dombrowski.

    Thank you,