If you saw that The Red Turtle came from Hayao Miyazaki’s Studio Ghibli and figured this was another charmer from the producers of My Neighbor Totoro and Spirited Away, well, allow me to disabuse you of that notion. This 80-minute, dialogue-free film, which was nominated for the Academy Award for Best Animated Feature this year, is by turns dark, pensive, and bizarre, operating almost entirely on a metaphorical level to elevate its paper-thin plot to something much more. And I still couldn’t really tell you how much I liked the film.
The movie opens with a man apparently surviving a shipwreck and washing up on a very remote tropical island, from which he begins to try to escape by building rather ornate rafts. Each time he tries to sail away, however, an unseen creature, which turns out to be the turtle of the title, smashes his raft to bits, so when the turtle comes ashore at one point, he attacks it and flips it over, leaving it to die. Somehow, this causes the turtle to morph into a woman, who then becomes the man’s mate, with the second half of the story following their life together as a couple and eventually parents of a young boy.
There isn’t even really that much of a story – we see a few events, like a tidal wave destroying much of the island, but so little happens here that I couldn’t process the movie in my head without immediately considering its possible metaphorical meanings. The arc of the entire movie has the main character starting at sea, landing, starting a family, growing old, and … well, the movie can only end in one or two ways, so I’ll leave it at that.
So what does the turtle/woman represent? I haven’t settled this in my own mind yet, but I think the turtle – the only red one in the film, as there are lots of turtles, but the rest are green – might stand in for maturity, or the way that the world forces maturity on us. Faced with the terrifying prospect of being stranded forever (growing up), the man tries to escape multiple times rather than facing the reality of the situation. The turtle prevents him from running away (and perhaps dying in the process), and only when he accepts that he has to stay can he continue with his life, at which point the turtle becomes his partner and eventually the mother of his child. But the turtle could represent commitment, or religion, or something else that he was fleeing before we first see him adrift in a storm.
The Red Turtle also has a strong ecological underpinning, with the man wholly dependent on the island for his survival. He begins by battling his environment, including the overt fight with the turtle, before submitting to his fate, and developing a way to support himself and eventually the woman and their child off what the island can provide them. If this was a deliberate theme, it comes through more in the animation itself than the story; the natural elements, especially the water and the foliage, around the island are drawn more delicately and thoroughly, with greater depth and complexity of color, than the relatively plain, barely-drawn people. If nothing else, I inferred that the filmmaker, Michaël Dudok de Wit, loves nature.
The film as a whole is dark, visually, in literal contrast to the other four nominees plus Finding Dory. The combination of the muted color palette and the lack of dialogue or significant action made the film seem a lot longer than it actually was; I enjoy some philosophical works of fiction, whether on the page or the screen, but perhaps The Red Turtle left too much of the deep thinking to me rather than putting it on the screen. This is the movie that wins the art film festival award, but if I were an Oscar voter, I would put it fourth among the four nominees I’ve seen for the category. (I haven’t seen My Life as a Zucchini yet, but I saw the trailer before this film, and it’s bright and colorful and looks absolutely fantastic; it opens in Philly on March 4th and here in Wilmington a week later.)
How would you rank the 4? I saw Moana and Zootopia with an almost-4-year-old. I thought the former was truly fantastic, most notably because of how complex and nuanced the characters were. No simple good-guy/bad-guy story, every character had motivations that made sense. This made such an imprrssion on my son, who teally atruggles to understand meanness/evil as it is often depicted in children’s media.
I’m struggling to get ALL the fanfare for Zootopia. It was good but dodn’t stand out.
I’m with you 100%.
Man finding Dory was simply awful – has it really been nominated for an Oscar? I hate it….Moana is 10 times better – maybe 50 times better…and Zootopia was ok – way better than Secret life of pets or finding Dory junk
Hi Keith,
Glad to see that you reviewed the Red Turtle. I think it’s a fantastic film that isn’t getting the buzz that it deserves. I found it refreshing that this film doesn’t spoon-feed its metaphorical meanings and life lessons; it’s left to the audience to interpret them as they may, much like real life. For me, the fact that the film was dialogue-free only created a heightened awareness of the environment and events – subtle or otherwise – that pushed the storyline forward. I read an interview with the director where he stated that the film itself is an expression of his love for nature. He wanted to express how we feel when we are in nature, how the cycle of life mirrors nature: beginning, growing, and disappearing. Much like the sea turtle appears from the infinity, with great effort lays eggs on the beach, and then returns to the infinity of the sea. The night scenes on the beach, with only light and shadow at the filmmaker’s disposal, were extraordinary beautiful.
As an aside, I read your review for Moonlight as well. Might you draw a parallel between the discomfort you felt from the silences in Moonlight and the absence of dialogue in Red Turtle?
My discomfort with Moonlight‘s silences was with one character failing to answer another, not from silence for its own sake. I have the same reaction to phones ringing in film or on TV – someone had better answer it before the fourth ring or I’ll lose my mind.