Kansas City eats.

I posted some quick reactions to Sunday’s Futures Game a few hours after it ended. Next ESPN post will be Thursday’s top 50 prospects update.

The best Q I had on in Kansas City was the burnt ends platter at the original Oklahoma Joe’s location (that is, attached to a gas station). This absolutely lived up to its advance billing, as the meat had great smoke flavor and the characteristic tooth of real burnt ends (although not the crispy exterior I expected – I admit I’m not a big burnt ends expert, though), without being so dry that sauce was required. Smoke rings were evident throughout, not that I needed proof after tasting them. The French fries were just fair; many of you recommended them and I’m guessing it’s because of the red pepper-based seasoning rather than for the fries themselves, which weren’t as good as what you’d get at Five Guys or In-n-Out. I’d try the beans for a side next time. The insider tip is to call your order in ahead of time, but I spent most of the ~45 minutes in line chatting with the two sports nuts behind me, as well as one of you who spotted my tweet about being in line.

Next-best was Jack Stack, which is solid Q at a table-service restaurant, the most expensive Q I’ve ever eaten by a wide margin. Their signature item is a beef short rib, given some absurd marketing name (“Crown Prime Beef Rib” or whatever, it’s a freaking short rib, get over yourselves), and since that is by far my favorite cut of cow I was all in. It’s extremely well done with a lot of surface area for bark and plenty of fat (maybe too much, but that’s the cut) to keep the interior meat moist through a long, slow smoke. Their pork burnt ends were just chopped pork chunks with a little bark, really nothing special. The beans were outstanding though – sweet, smoky, salty, very slightly tangy, maybe a little too soft, although that’s the style (I like beans just a little past al dente). The seasonal vegetable was asparagus, funny because asparagus is a spring vegetable, but they did do a nice job of cooking it correctly so it wasn’t stringy or mushy. Service could not have been better, Q joint or otherwise. The total cost including iced tea and tip was $36, though.

Last Q joint was Gates, which disappointed. I may have ordered the wrong thing – more on that later – but I got no help from the kids behind the counter who seemed to have no interest in taking my order. I went with the short-end ribs, since ribs seemed to dominate the menu, but they were dry, tough, not smoky, and drowned in a vinegar-pepper sauce.

I had Sunday brunch – yes, I rolled out of bed around 9:30, thanks to the time difference – at Bluestem Cafe, which had a small line out the door before it opened at 10:30, usually a good sign. The special breakfast sandwich of the day comprised an over-easy egg on top of pulled pork with very crispy potato wedges and a small salad of mixed greens, a pretty significant amount of food for lunch and enough to hold me through the Futures Game. The pork was moist but the sauce was vinegary, so this could have been braised rather than smoked and I wouldn’t have known the difference. Everything else was clearly fresh and high quality, and they get extra points for the cute bartender.

I tried Eggtc for breakfast on Monday morning, looking for something quick but still local, although the quality just wasn’t there. The eggs on the benedict were poached too long – or poached earlier and held – so they had started to cook through, and since the greatest pleasure of eggs benedict is the sauce made by the warm but runny yolk, this was kind of a failure. The home fries had also clearly come out of a bag.

Finally, I have to thank all of you who weighed in on Q options for my weekend, including Jeff Passan of Yahoo! and Brooks Melchior of Sports by Brooks (via his Twitter feed). Brooks says my next trip to KC should include a visit for Stroud’s for fried chicken and cinnamon rolls and a second chance for Gates where I order the “beef and a half” sandwich rather than ribs.

Comments

  1. Dang, now I’m REALLY hungry. My wife is from KC (we live in Mpls now), but we’ll be taking some friends down next weekend for the Twins/Royals series and for a BBQ and beer tour. Gates is fast food bbq, but worth a trip just for the treatment. Also Arthur Bryants is a must see just for the history, and the good food. And yeah, Strouds is outstanding, but I think I just gained 5lbs thinking about the place.

  2. You can probably skip Stroud’s. It’s decent, but will weigh you down, more so than any BBQ would. Instead, check out LC’s for some of the best burnt ends in town. Then again, you could probably spend an entire month hitting every joint that people will recommend. Such a great problem to have here.

  3. Pretty essential that you make your way to Arthur Bryants. when you do, don’t waste your time with ribs or something like that. you need to get a “sandwich.” which, basically consists of white bread, sauce, choice of meat, sauce, white bread, sauce, choice of meat, sauce, white bread, sauce.

    you can pick your meat choices, they’re all good. I happen to prefer, the short rib and the chicken. but, to each their own.

    also, make sure to get it to-go, even if you are eating it there. I put the word “sandwich” in quotation marks, because this certainly isn’t a sandwich that you will be picking up with your hands. when you get it to go, it’s basically wrapped into a big ball with a generous handful of fries. the basic purpose of the bread and fries is to soak up the excess sauce, which you will undoubtedly add more of to the mix if you are eating there with a bottle of it in front of you.

    happy eating.

  4. Keith, you didn’t go to the best BBQ joint in KC — LC’s! It’s a little hole in the wall, which naturally means the food is delicious.

  5. I was glad to see you confirm my thoughts on gates after having relatives from kc hype it up so much. The service there almost went out of its way to make my party feel uncomfortable there and the sauce was by far the weakest of the kc style sauces I tried that weekend while the meat was very average

  6. Chad… What’s the reason to order to-go?

    Also, the Sweet Heat sauce at Bryants is some of my favorite. I always bring home a few bottles, though the newly bottled Oklahoma Joe’s sauce is pretty incredible, just more expensive.

  7. One other to try, if you’re alright with stepping outside the expected cuisine of Kansas City, is Pizza Bella. Full disclosure: I worked with the owner when we were both in the employ of Pachamamas, a Lawrence fine dining establishment also very much worth visiting (locally sourced food, rotating menu – pachamamas.com).

    Anyways, the husband and wife-owned Pizza Bella is worth the trip and exciting to find in a city that so often favors the heavy-handed over the sublime. http://www.pizzabellakc.com/

    Enjoy all your posts, baseball and otherwise.

    Best,

    Z

  8. Regarding the overcooked “over easy” eggs…do you ever send them back? Probably 10% of the time when I get mine closer to over-medium (or god forbic, over-hard), I’ll show the waiter and they’re very understanding in taking them back for an over easy. Maybe I’m rude, but if it’s overcooked, I want no part of it.

  9. I went to Arthur Bryant’s last year and when I first ate I was disappointed. Then I tried their other sauces and it was outstanding. I’m not sure what it was about the original sauce, maybe too much vinegar for my taste, but it seemed off. Next time you go to Jack Stack, try their cheesy corn bake for a side. Can’t wait to get back to KC to try some of the places you’ve mentioned.

  10. I second the LC’s rec (as I did earlier in a tweet, as well). It’s a shell of its former self, phoning it in day after day and counting on its established name to pay the bills.
    For some good breakfast or brunch next time around check out You Say Tomato, which is in a great neighborhood, too. The chicken salad and the quiche are both stellar.
    What’d you think of Kauffman Stadium?

  11. Whoa, my “shell of its former self” comment is about Gates, not LC’s. I let myself get distracted and didn’t edit myself.

  12. Gates is vastly overrated. Had the same exact experience as you Keith, and that was 9yrs ago. Surprised that place is still in business.

  13. Strouds is by far the best restaurant in America for pure grub/good eats. The guy above that complained it weighs you down must be an idiot. In fact, pass on the superb fried chicken, the best at Strouds is chicken fried steak and blackened pork chops. The rolls at the end are incredible. I”ve been all over, Strouds is the best.

  14. As you can tell, opinions on Stroud’s are a bit mixed. They are a great value for sure: lots of good food for a modest price. But their food isn’t so exceptional that I would recommend them to an out-of-town visitor that only has to time to visit a limited number of restaurants.

    As for Gate’s, if you get them on a good day, they are some of the best barbecue you can find. But their problem in my experience is that they are very inconsistent. I don’t go there as often as I used to because it seems like 1 out of every 4 meals would be crap and I got sick of that gamble. You must’ve lost. If you do give them another chance, I recommend the mixed plate. Search YouTube for “Gates Mixed Plate” for an awesome video that KC native Tech N9ne made about that meal.

    And because I don’t comment here often, I just want to take this opportunity to say that I love your board game reviews. They are the reason I started following your blog.