Top 12 songs of 2010.

I won’t pretend that this is any sort of canonical list of the best songs of 2010, or even the best alternative songs of 2010; it’s merely a list of the best songs I heard, songs I liked and would recommend if your musical taste echoes mine at all. Feel free to throw your own suggestions in the comments below, as well as the usual complaints about how I’m biased against The National.

I limited the list to songs released in the 2010 calendar year, so Phoenix, which dominated alternative radio all spring and summer, doesn’t qualify, since Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix came out in May of 2009.

Linked song titles go to videos; links to amazon or iTunes to purchase come after the title.

12. Ted Leo & the Pharmacists – The Mighty Sparrow. (amazon/iTunes) When the cafe doors exploded, I … ran for cover. OK, the lyrics are a little peculiar, but I like the straight-edge post-punk energy behind this song even if Leo does sound like he’s on the verge of laryngitis.

11. Cut Copy – “Where I’m Going.” (Still a free download at Cut Copy’s site.) Straight-up early Britpop from an Australian band, with a shout-along chorus and the sort of neutered harmonies in the vocals that characterized a lot of lesser acts in the earlier movement. I suppose if I was truly playing music critic I’d either praise the song’s hook-laden simplicity or criticize its derivative music and tired lyrics. Whatever I think, I can’t credibly claim that I didn’t like the song. A lot.

10. Ra Ra Riot – “Boy.” (amazon/iTunes) I’m pulling for these guys even though I found their album pretty uneven, with “Boy” the high point. We don’t see enough bands trying to do something so different while still staying within the rough confines of alternative music – you can hear strong new wave influences here – and their use of unusual song structures and string instruments does them credit.

9. Limousines – “Internet Killed the Video Star.” (iTunes) I could see this song crossing over to the pop charts because the chorus is so catchy, and for a supposedly “experimental” band they’ve put out a very straightforward song here that merges rock and electronic elements in a song that purports to defend the guitar against the computer. By the way, kids – that drum machine ain’t got no soul.

8. Sleigh Bells – “Rill Rill.” (amazon/iTunes) The rest of the Sleigh Bells album is unlistenable, but this song’s relentless, almost sing-songy lyric hooked me from first listen and brought back memories of the 1990s trip-hop anthem “6 Underground.” Besides, there’s something enchanting about the (presumed) teenage-girl narrator breaking with stereotype when she answers the question, “Wonder what your boyfriend thinks about your braces?” with the defiant, “What about them? I’m all about them.”

7. Tame Impala – “Solitude Is Bliss.” (iTunes) Another album that didn’t quite live up to the first track I heard, but this psychedelic, stop-and-start ode to living inside one’s own head reached out of the radio and grabbed me. The bizarre video is inventive given what appears to have been a very low budget.

6. Belle & Sebastian – “Ghost of Rockschool.” (amazon/iTunes) A mournful, mystical track from the underrated and understated Scottish masters of ironic rock, not their best song (that would be the incomparable “The Boy With The Arab Strap”) but the best on their newest album. The hint of brass brought me back to one of my favorite bands of the ’90s, Animals that Swim, who never quite found an audience for their albums of original tracks that sounded like drinking songs.

5. Dead Weather – “Blue Blood Blues .” (amazon/iTunes) I was surprised to read that Jack White plays drums for Dead Weather when the meaty, heavy guitar riffs on this song sound so much like his recent style. It’s sludgy, almost Kyuss-esque with better production and cleaner lines.

4. Arcade Fire – “Sprawl II (Mountains Beyond Mountains).” (amazon/iTunes) On an album about our sprawling suburban society, where culture is found in the yogurt section of the local grocery store, “Sprawl II” provides the most withering vocal attack over a very new wave-influenced track laced with synthesizers. I don’t love the singer’s breathy, thin voice, but you can always drown that out by singing along.

3. Broken Bells – “The High Road.” (amazon/iTunes) So Danger Mouse is good for one knockout song per collaborative album, right? This one, with James Mercer from the Shins, features a two-tiered vocal married to a split instrumental track, with an acoustic guitar line behind the laconic verse switching to trip-hoppy electronic sounds as Mercer brings his voice up an octave. This also spawned my first (and still only) YTMND effort.

2. Arcade Fire – “City With No Children.” (amazon/iTunes) From the start, it was my favorite track on one of the best rock albums I’ve ever purchased, and while I know many of you disagree, I think that’s more a function of how strong and deep The Suburbs is; if half the songs on this list came from that album I doubt I would have received many complaints. The absence of typical percussion and the muted sound of the lead guitar in “City” paint a desolate backdrop for lyrics describing not just alienation but self-reflection and ecological decay.

1. Mumford & Sons – “Little Lion Man.” (amazon/iTunes) A perfect marriage of alt-rock/emo angst and English folk music, with a perfectly deployed four-letter word of Anglo-Saxon origin (six letters as a past participle). The entire album (just $5 at amazon yet again) is a marvel, from “Winter Winds” to “White Blank Page” to “Roll Away Your Stone,” but “Little Lion Man” had the strongest hook, and its crossover on to American radio and eventual gold certification was one of the biggest stories in music this year.

Comments

  1. Loved Ted Leo’s The Brutalist Bricks all around. In my top 10 albums this year, maybe top 5.

    The one song that came out of nowhere to me was J Roddy Walston & the Business’s “Brave Man’s Death”.

  2. Little Lion Man is a great song. If you want to take it to the next level then Rye Whiskey by Punch Brothers is a fun song. I, for some reason, have sort of gravitated towards the folk/bluegrass genre this year.

    Also, Phoenix Burn by Alpha Rev is not a folk song, but is fantastic just the same.

  3. All in all a solid list. I would put “Modern Man” off of THE SUBURBS in there somewhere and I’m not as sold on Mumford and Sons as most but I applaud your adventurous nature. Enjoy your work and look forward to reading you in 2011.

  4. Fave Mumford song is the cave. Fave song of the year “On Melancholy Hill” by Gorillaz.

  5. Totally agree on Brave Man’s Death. Awesome song. Other favorites: Megafaun’s “Volunteers” and The Black Keys’ “The Only One”,

  6. “Awake My Soul” is my favorite song on the Mumford & Sons album, which is excellent all the way through.

  7. Keith, I am curious, what’s your beef with James Mercer/The Shins?

  8. Adam: Huh?

    Jon: Can’t do “Modern Man.” Not as nails-on-the-chalkboard annoying as “Rococo,” but definitely not among my favorites, musically or lyrically.

  9. this is in my top 5, dessa released her first cd on an independent label here in minneapolis.. she has gotten a lot of press locally, but i’d imagine you’ve never heard of her.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F8dt8mY2WiQ

  10. Sorry Keith…When I read this on Google Reader I could have sworn it said “so and so from the Shins,” and also referred to him as “X.” I thought that you were jabbing at him, but now I realize that maybe I just saw an early version of this post. Or maybe I am just crazy.

  11. I would agree that “The High Road” is the best track on Broken Bells, but I also love “The Ghost Inside” and “October.”

  12. Adam: I wrote this offline and forgot to look up his name before posting.

  13. Personal favorite from The Suburbs is “Suburban War.” I also enjoyed the Ben Folds/Nick Hornby project with “Picture Window” being my favorite and Bob Schneider’s duet with Patty Griffin “Changing Your Mind.”
    Enjoy reading your work (even if you hate the Cardinals and the National). Have a great New Year!

  14. Hate to focus on omissions, but are you familiar with The Walkmen? They quietly put out another great album this year: ‘Lisbon’. Standout tracks include: “Angela Surf City”, “Juveniles”, and “Woe is Me”.

  15. Top 11 in alphabetical order except #1 …

    Avi Buffalo – “Whats in it For?”
    Beach House – “Norway”
    Fences – “Girls with Accents”
    The National – “Bloodbuzz Ohio”
    The Morning Benders – “All Day Day Light”
    Local Natives – “Airplanes”
    Ra Ra Riot – “Boy”
    Sun Airway – “American West”
    Surfer Blood – “Swim”
    Yeasayer – “ONE”

    #1 … Deerhunter – “Desire Lines”

  16. Keith, have you listened to The Black Keys? If not, I recommend them. Their album, Brothers, is my favorite of the year.

  17. My favorite song of the year is “All I Want” by LCD Soundsystem.

    Honorable mentions that have so far gone unmentioned:

    “F*ck You” – Cee Lo Green
    “When I’m With You” – Best Coast

  18. Stephen: I have Lisbon, listened to it once. Nothing grabbed me and I haven’t gotten back to it with travel/everyone getting sick.

    Ken: Yes, not really a fan. I can’t place it but I feel like they’re very derivative of something I’ve heard before, maybe in the early ’90s.

    Dave: “O.N.E.” didn’t have staying power for me. I hate that Fences song – really, congratulations, you learned the F word, maybe now you should learn how to use it like an adult.

  19. I agree with Stephen regarding The Walkmen. Anyway, Keith, good list. “Ready to Start” is easily my favorite track off The Suburbs, but the two you covered above are also excellent.

    P.S.

    It’s a shame you’re not a fan of The National.

  20. Aw, Keith, unlistenable? I really like “Crown on the Ground” and a few others.

  21. I like your list a lot Keith. I would, however, like to get your thoughts on Ray Lamontagne’s album. I thought it was at least the second best album of the year, behind Arcade Fire’s.

  22. Am I the only one who thinks every song by The National sounds like every other song by The National??

  23. It’s good to see the inclusion of Sprawl II. It’s my favourite track on the album and as far as I know it hasn’t been released as a single. Some other songs I enjoyed from the past year:

    Black Keys – Tighten Up
    Arcade Fire – Modern Man
    The Gaslight Anthem – The Diamond Church Street Choir
    B.o.B. – Airplanes
    Stars – Wasted Daylight
    Talib Kweli – Strangers (Paranoid)
    Maurice – Robin

  24. “Am I the only one who thinks every song by The National sounds like every other song by The National??”

    They don’t really create singles; their albums, especially the last two, are very cohesive start to finish so I imagine they do blend more than most artists. Plus, Berninger has a very distinct voice and most tracks are driven by the drum beat. All probably contribute although a super-fan like myself would beg to differ.

    ““O.N.E.” didn’t have staying power for me.”

    I wasn’t enamoured with the album version have really liked the live versions. One here: http://kexp.org/live/liveperformance.aspx?rID=31289

    “I hate that Fences song – really, congratulations, you learned the F word, maybe now you should learn how to use it like an adult.”

    The song is about immaturity.

  25. No love for Flo? My wife and I really enjoy Florence and the Machine. Anything you are looking forward to (music-wise) in ’11?

  26. Wow Dave…that’s quite the list! I feel like I’m the only one that listen to Avi, Local Natives, and the almighty Deerhunter.

    Keith – great point on how deep The Suburbs is. I think City with no Children is one of the worst songs on the album, but that in no way means that I think it’s a bad song. My personal favorite on the album would definitely be “The Suburbs”, “Ready to Start”, and “Sprawl II”. Man, the lyrics on “The Suburbs” are way too fantastic…I don’t get why people discredit that one.

  27. Love that Mumford & Sons album. Check out “Common Faults” by The Silent Comedy. Similar sound, to my ear.

  28. I think I mentioned this here before, but I’m not a huge Mumford & Sons (or Avett Bros, who sound really similar to me) fan but, in that same genre, Seattle’s Head and the Heart are really solid. If you like M&S, you’ll probably like them.

  29. I like Mumford and Sons as well. Little Lion Man is a really fun song but they seem like a one trick pony band. Most of the songs start slow, go very fast, and repeat. Feel like they’re an amazing house/bar band but I’m not sure we’ll see much more.

  30. Thanks for posting the list, Keith, I always enjoy the music posts. My top 10 songs of 2010 (in no particular order):

    The Cribs – We Share the Same Skies
    Surfer Blood – Swim
    The Duke Spirit – Everybody’s Under Your Spell
    Arcade Fire – Sprawl II
    The Drums – Let’s Go Surfing
    Free Energy – Bang Pop
    Broken Bells – The High Road
    Kisses – Bermuda
    Matt & Kim – Cameras
    Soundgarden – Black Rain

    Fun year for music, looking forward to 2011 (especially, I must admit, Beady Eye’s first album. Go Liam!).

  31. Anything you are looking forward to (music-wise) in ’11?

    The Cloud Nothings’ eponymous album, due out in January.

  32. Second anticipating Cloud Nothings. Okkervil River are supposed to have a new one coming out, Bon Iver, M83, Noah & the Whale, Pains of Being Pure at Heart (although a flop wouldn’t shock me), bands I’ve never heard of but will love in a year …

    (Also, Fences is doing a live at KEXP session right now. Ironic in the loosest sense of the word.)

  33. Keith, list looks good, and good to see a fellow Belle & Sebastian fan. I wonder if you’re a fan of another Glaswegian band Teenage Fanclub and if so, what did you think of their great 2010 release,’ Shadows’?

  34. Nice list Keith. Wanted to ask you what you thought about last summer’s surf/noise pop bands like Best Coast, Wavves, etc.

  35. Thanks for the list! I also really liked Phosphorescent’s album. The Mermaid Parade is an incredible song.

  36. Keith nice list, I totally agree with some of the other readers “The Black Keys” album was good. Its like there 5th or 6th. However there 1st 2 (specifically the 1st, “The Big Come Up”) are great. “Busted”, “Yearnin”, “I’ll Be Your Man” are all incredible. They even did a hip hop cd with a number of big names in rap where they produced all the music in studio with the MC’s. Its called “BlakRoc” and both songs featuring Jim Jones are epic….I’ve just started reading your blog but have been reading your chats and articles on ESPN for about 14 months. Love it and hope you check out the Keys.

  37. i love the entire album “suburbs” by the arcade fire. its just as good as “funeral” and i never thought they could come close to achieving that again. my favorite song of the year however is “dancing on my own” by robyn. its the perfect pop song. who would’ve thought that after she made a splash in the late 90’s with silly songs that coined her as the australian britney spears she would come back 10 years later with an amazing self titled album followed by an equally incredible album called “body talk.” there is nothing pretentious about this song. just great vocals, a catchy hook, and flawless production. also shout outs to this year go to lcd soundsystem, yeasayer, and kanye west.

  38. Sincere question Keith – why do you feel the F word in Little Lion Man an asset but in Girls With Accents it’s immature? Similar contexts, how do you reconcile?

  39. Not even remotely similar contexts.