More NYC pizza and gelato.

Today’s Klawchat went well, I think. I’ll be back on BBTN tonight at 1:30 am Eastern.

I’ve gotten to two more spots from that (somewhat dubious) Food and Wine list of the nation’s best pizzerias, both in Manhattan, home to eleven of the 43 restaurants to make their cut. I still have five left in New York City, three of which (Di Fara, Paulie Gee’s, Sottocasa) are tricky because their hours are limited.

Forcella boasts three locations in the city, with the original in Brooklyn; I went to their NoHo location, on the Bowery between 2nd and 3rd (that’s Manhattan, for those of you unfamiliar with NYC neighborhoods). Their biggest claim to fame is as one of the first pizzerias, perhaps the first, to introduce the Neapolitan style of pizza known as “pizza montanara,” where the dough is quickly deep-fried to set and slightly crisp the crust, after which it’s topped and baked in a hot oven like most authentic Neapolitan pizzas are. This was my first experience with any kind of fried pizza, so I have no means of comparison, but I can say it was spectacular – the direct contact of the hot oil with the crust produces far more caramelization of the exterior starches and sugars than you’ll get from the indirect heat of a hotter oven, and there’s a hint of the flavor of a zeppole (the Italian take on fried dough, often served in a paper bag and drowned in powdered sugar). The crushed tomatoes were bright and very sweet, but I might argue for a little more cheese so you’re not just eating a plate of (delicious) fried bread. It is a steal at $9, by the way.


Pizza montanara at Forcella.

Rubirosa is a full-fledged Italian restaurant that happens to serve very good pizza. I saw it on Mulberry Street, between Prince and Spring, a fairly unassuming storefront that hides a larger seating area in the back. Rubirosa’s pizza isn’t true Neapolitan style, as it has very little exterior “lip” and is more cracker-like underneath, as opposed to the traditional wet-centered Neapolitan style. While the toppings were a little more generous than those at Forcella, the tomatoes weren’t as bright and their acidity overpowered the rest of the pizza because the crust was so thin. I enjoy these crispier crusts, like those at the Grimaldi’s chain in Arizona (I haven’t tried their NY outposts yet), but it’s a different product than true Neapolitan pizza, where you can really taste and feel the craft of the baker behind the bread. Also, at $17 for a small pizza, it’s overpriced for what you get.

Mo’ Gelato‘s coffee gelato is some of the strongest-flavored I’ve ever tasted, although that’s not saying much considering how most coffee-flavored gelatos, even those dubbed “espresso” flavor, often taste about as much like coffee as a light-and-sweet cup of swill from Dunkin’ Donuts. Mo’ Gelato’s looks darker and tastes it, so that the sweetness has real balance from the sharp note of roasted coffee. Their chocolate sorbet was a little pale in comparison, even though its color and flavor are both very dark – the lack of any kind of additional fat created a hollow flavor that, paired with the butterfat in the coffee gelato, seemed flat.

Il Buco Alimentaria is an Italian market and sandwich/small plates shop that also serves a small selection of gelato flavors, about eight when I visited, dished up by a rather fetching Sicilian woman who looked about as Italian as I do (which is to say, not much). Their chocolate gelato was superb, very smooth with a pudding-like flavor and texture, a rich semi-sweet chocolate that wasn’t extremely dark but less cloying or sweet than milk chocolate. The caramel gelato, however, was way too mild; in an era of sea salt caramel gelato and ice cream, weak caramel flavors just won’t cut it.

The next pizza stop will probably be Via Tribunali, an import to Manhattan from Seattle that is the only one of the F&W pizzerias in Manhattan that I haven’t tried and that is open for lunch.

Comments

  1. Keith, if you ever need new NYC pizza ideas, check out this instagram… http://instagram.com/nycpizzagram

  2. If you ever make it up to Fordham Rd, make sure to check out Zero Otto Nove (I highly recommend their butternut squash purée, cream of truffle, mushrooms w/ fresh mozzarella pizza.

  3. Happy to pass on pizza recommendations – Rubirosa is right in my hood! In same area I’d think about Emporio, L’asso. And Lab del Gelato for gelato, if you haven’t had it before.

  4. RE: klawchat. This:

    Dammit, Nick, I can’t answer that, because I’m not a doctor.

    Literally laughed out loud. Admit it, you were just *waiting* for someone to ask a question you could answer that way.

  5. @SethH: I really wasn’t. I find the chats are funnier if I don’t plan anything in advance.

    @Philair: Same as the one in Armonk? I drive right by that every time I go up to Bristol.

    @Danny: Laboratorio is fabulous. Just been trying to branch out. Emporio over l’Asso for you?

  6. If you’re getting off I-684 in Armonk, skip Zero Otto Nove and go to Fortina, which is in the downtown Armonk. Much better pizza, appetizers and pastas.

  7. Hey Klaw,

    I’m something of a pizza snob, not something I pride myself on, just something that comes with the territory being born and raised in New Haven, CT. Growing up my favorite pie was the clam and bacon (with extra garlic) from Sally’s, but given the lines, our go to was usually Modern. I’ve since moved on to New York, and found some solid pizza being put out, but I still have a soft spot for home.

    That being said, there’s a new addition to New Haven’s big four (Sally’s, Pepe’s, Modern and Bar) that I implore you to check out if you’re ever in town. In my opinion they blow the competition out of the water. They’re called Da Legna, located on State Street close to Modern. I would be happy to recommend a particular pizza, but frankly you can’t go wrong with their specialty pies, and even their small plates (their duck bolognese is awesome) are great.

    Cheers!

  8. Emporio v. L’asso is a tough call! If you have to try one, probably Emporio. L’asso has great crust and sauce, but it’s more of an ‘everyday eating’ place (albeit one I’m extremely happy to have across the street). Emporio a little more flair. Or give me a call and we can split one of each.

    As for gelato, appreciate desire for variety, but you won’t top Lab anyway! In the same hood as above though, could go for A.B. Biagi, if you want to try something different.